Abstract:The instrumental variable method consistently estimates the effect of a treatment when there is unmeasured confounding and a valid instrumental variable. A valid instrumental variable is a variable that is independent of unmeasured confounders and affects the treatment but does not have a direct effect on the outcome beyond its effect on the treatment. Two commonly used estimators for using an instrumental variable to estimate a treatment effect are the two stage least squares estimator and the control function estimator. For linear causal effect models, these two estimators are equivalent, but for nonlinear causal effect models, the estimators are different. We provide a systematic comparison of these two estimators for nonlinear causal effect models and develop an approach to combing the two estimators that generally performs better than either one alone. We show that the control function estimator is a two stage least squares estimator with an augmented set of instrumental variables. If these augmented instrumental variables are valid, then the control function estimator can be much more efficient than usual two stage least squares without the augmented instrumental variables while if the augmented instrumental variables are not valid, then the control function estimator may be inconsistent while the usual two stage least squares remains consistent. We apply the Hausman test to test whether the augmented instrumental variables are valid and construct a pretest estimator based on this test. The pretest estimator is shown to work well in a simulation study. An application to the effect of exposure to violence on time preference is considered.

Generalized Instrumental Variables

Instrumental Variables: An Econometrician's Perspective

The Instrumental Variable Model with Categorical Instrument, Treatment and Outcome: Characterization, Partial Identification, and Statistical Inference

Bayesian variable selection in linear regression models with instrumental variables

Reading and conducting instrumental variable studies: guide, glossary, and checklist

Sequential Underspecified Instrument Selection for Cause-Effect Estimation

Causal Bounds and Instruments

Testability of Instrumental Variables in Linear Non-Gaussian Acyclic Causal Models

Valid Causal Inference with (Some) Invalid Instruments

Discovering Ancestral Instrumental Variables for Causal Inference From Observational Data

Instrumental variables: A non-asymptotic viewpoint

Control Function Instrumental Variable Estimation of Nonlinear Causal Effect Models

Kernel Instrumental Variable Regression

Ancestral Instrument Method for Causal Inference without Complete Knowledge

Instrumental variable analysis in the presence of unmeasured confounding

Logic,Imagination and Interpretation:The application of instrumental variables for causal inference in the social sciences

Identifying Causal Effects using Instrumental Time Series: Nuisance IV and Correcting for the Past

Testability of Instrumental Variables in Additive Nonlinear, Non-Constant Effects Models

Estimation and inference for high-dimensional nonparametric additive instrumental-variables regression

Instrumental variables as bias amplifiers with general outcome and confounding

Bounding Causal Effects with Leaky Instruments