Abstract:The paper reports a study that examined the impact of the interaction of task complexity manipulations and language proficiency on second-language writing performance. Increased cognitive complexity in tasks has been shown to benefit writing in terms of syntactic and lexical complexity; the quantum of benefit defined by language proficiency notwithstanding. The study manipulated task complexity and studied the impact on written production of learners at two different levels of proficiency in English and wished to contribute to the debate that Robinson’s Cognition Hypothesis (2001a, b) and Skehan & Foster’s Limited Attentional Capacity Model (1997) sparked off about the facilitative or adverse impact of task complexity on production. It also wished to see how language proficiency interacts with task complexity to affect L2 written production. On the basis of an English proficiency test that included reading, writing, speaking, vocabulary and grammar, 30 learners of age range 23–38 years were categorized as lower (N = 15) and higher proficiency (N = 15) groups. The lower proficiency group were students of Bachelor’s degree in English, Engineering, Science or Computers and had an average of 10 years of English instruction. The high proficiency participants were pursuing their doctoral studies in Humanities with at least 12–15 years of English medium instruction. Five tasks were manipulated for cognitive complexity: [−complex] tasks required learners to describe a product that their company is planning to launch in the market (a descriptive task), and the [+complex] version required learners to take a standpoint on which product a customer should go with: an attractive, not so high quality one or an unattractive one but high quality. The standpoint needed to support with arguments (an argumentative task). The written production was assessed on five linguistic measures—syntactic complexity, syntactic variety, lexical density, lexical variety and accuracy. The main findings of the study were: (i) proficiency affected written performance in all dimensions except frequency of reference markers, high proficiency learners with better scores than lower proficiency learners, (ii) complexity increase affected the two groups differently—it increased syntactic complexity and lexical variety in higher group, and not in lower group; it decreased lexical density and variety in lower group, and (iii) accuracy remained unaffected, calling into question Skehan’s main claim of the Limited Capacity Model. A task difficulty questionnaire administered post the tasks showed an increase in thinking and perception of stress and decreased interest in both groups, suggesting that the task complexity manipulations are also psychologically real. The findings of the study validate Robinson’s Cognition Hypothesis that a focused attention on complexity is not at the expense of accuracy especially for high proficiency learners, though the effect of task complexity on written performance is modulated by language proficiency.

Challenging the connection between task perceptions and language use in L2 writing: Genre, cognitive task complexity, and linguistic complexity

Genre Effect on L2 Syntactic Complexity and Holistic Rating for Writing Quality of Intermediate EFL Learners

EXAMINING THE RELATIVE EFFECTS OF TASK COMPLEXITY AND COGNITIVE DEMANDS ON STUDENTS’ WRITING IN A SECOND LANGUAGE

Effects of Task Complexity on L2 Writing Behaviors and Linguistic Complexity

Writing task complexity, students’ motivational beliefs, anxiety and their writing production in English as a second language

Task Complexity and Language Proficiency: Its Effect on L2 Writing Production

Task complexity, task repetition, and L2 writing complexity: exploring interactions in the TBLT domain

Author Response for "effects of Speaker Types and L1 Backgrounds on the Linguistic Complexity of Learners’ Writing"

Exploring the potential of second/foreign language writing for language learning: The effects of task factors and learner variables

Cognitive task complexity and second language writing performance

Task complexity and linguistic and discourse features of narrative writing performance

Influence of Task Complexity on Text Features and Writing Scores: Evidence from College Students in Southern China

Effects of Task Complexity and Planning Conditions on L2 Argumentative Writing Production

Syntactic Complexity Development in the Writings of EFL Learners: Insights from a Dependency Syntactically-Annotated Corpus

Task-based Explanation for Genre Effects: Evidence from a Dependency Treebank.

Syntactic complexity in college-level English writing: Differences among writers with diverse L1 backgrounds

How do EFL learners process oral tasks with different complexity: an exploratory study

The Effects of Mode and Task Complexity on Second Language Production

L2 writing anxiety, working memory, and task complexity in L2 written performance

Task complexity and measures of linguistic performance in L2 writing

Task complexity and foreign language writing emotions as predictors of EFL writing performance