Comparison of HAV and HCV infections in vivo and in vitro reveals distinct patterns of innate immune evasion and activation

Ombretta Colasanti,Rani Burm,Hao-En Huang,Tobias Riedl,Jannik Traut,Nadine Gillich,Teng-Feng Li,Laura Corneillie,Suzanne Faure-Dupuy,Oliver Grünvogel,Danijela Heide,Ji-Young Lee,Cong Si Tran,Uta Merle,Maria Chironna,Katharina Esser-Nobis,Marco Binder,Ralf Bartenschlager,Mathias Heikenwälder,Philip Meuleman,Volker Lohmann,Florian F.W. Vondran
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhep.2023.04.023
IF: 25.7
2023-04-01
Journal of Hepatology
Abstract:BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Hepatitis A virus (HAV) infections are considered not to trigger innate immunity in vivo, in contrast to hepatitis C virus (HCV). This lack of induction has been imputed to strong interference by HAV proteases 3CD and 3ABC. We aimed at elucidating the mechanisms of immune activation and counteraction by HAV and HCV in vivo and in vitro.METHODS: UPA-SCID mice with humanized liver were infected with HAV and HCV. Hepatic cell culture models were used to assess HAV and HCV sensing by TLR3 and RIG-I/MDA5, respectively. Cleavage of the adaptor proteins TRIF and MAVS was analysed by transient and stable expression of HAV and HCV proteases and virus infection.RESULTS: We detected similar levels of Interferon stimulated genes (ISGs) induction in hepatocytes of HAV and HCV infected mice with humanized liver. In cell culture, HAV induced ISGs exclusively upon MDA5 sensing and depended on LGP2. TRIF and MAVS were only partially cleaved by HAV 3ABC and 3CD, not sufficiently to abrogate signalling. In contrast, HCV NS3-4 A efficiently degraded MAVS, as previously reported, whereas TRIF cleavage was not detected.CONCLUSIONS: HAV induces an innate immune response in hepatocytes via MDA5/LGP2, with limited control of both pathways by proteolytic cleavage. HCV activates TLR3 and lacks TRIF cleavage, suggesting that this pathway mainly contributes to HCV induced antiviral response in hepatocytes. Our results shed new light on induction and counteraction of innate immunity by HAV and HCV.
gastroenterology & hepatology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?