Abstract:Using CORSIKA simulations, we investigate the mass sensitivity of cosmic-ray air-shower observables for sites at the South Pole and Malargüe, Argentina, the respective locations of the IceCube Neutrino Observatory and the Pierre Auger Observatory. Exact knowledge of observables from air-shower simulations was used to study the event-by-event mass separation between proton, helium, oxygen, and iron primary cosmic rays with a Fisher linear discriminant analysis. Dependencies on the observation site as well as the energy and zenith angle of the primary particle were studied in the ranges from $10^{16.0}-10^{18.5}\,$eV and $0^\circ$ to $60^\circ$: they are mostly weak and do not change the qualitative results. Promising proton-iron mass separation is achieved using combined knowledge of all studied observables, also when typical reconstruction uncertainties are accounted for. However, even with exact measurements, event-by-event separation of intermediate-mass nuclei is challenging and better methods than the Fisher discriminant and/or the inclusion of additional observables will be needed. As an individual observable, high-energy muons ($> 500\,$GeV) provide the best event-by-event mass discrimination, but the combination of muons of any energy and $X_{\text{max}}$ provides already a high event-by-event separation between proton-iron primaries at both sites. We also confirm that the asymmetry and width parameters of the air-shower longitudinal profile, $R$ and $L$, are mass sensitive. Only $R$ seems to be suitable for event-by-event mass separation, but $L$ can potentially be used to statistically determine the proton-helium ratio. Overall, our results motivate the coincident measurement of several air-shower observables, including at least $X_{\text{max}}$ and the sizes of the muonic and electromagnetic shower components, for the next generation of air-shower experiments.

Identification of the primary mass of inclined cosmic ray showers from depth of maximum and number of muons parameters

Precise determination of muon shower content from shower universality property

On the possibility of primary identification of individual cosmic ray showers

New approach to primary mass composition analysis with simultaneous use of ground and fluorescence detectors data

UHECR primary identification using the lateral profile of muons in EAS

Search for UHE neutrinos in the background of cosmic rays

Reconstruction of air shower muon lateral distribution functions using integrator and binary modes of underground muon detectors

Studying the mass sensitivity of air-shower observables using simulated cosmic rays

Energy reconstruction of hadron-initiated showers of ultra-high energy cosmic rays

Precise determination of muon and EM shower contents from shower universality property

A Method for energy estimation and mass composition determination of primary cosmic rays at Chacaltaya observation level based on atmospheric Cerenkov light technique

A new potential method for the $X_{\rm max}$ measurement of extensive air showers based on backtracking radio signals

Identifying Extended PeVatron Sources via Neutrino Shower Detection

Determination of high-energy hadronic interaction properties from observables of proton initiated extensive air showers

A new observable in extensive air showers

Millicharged Particles from the Heavens: Single- and Multiple-Scattering Signatures

Prospects for direct cosmic ray mass measurements through the Gerasimova-Zatsepin effect

Muon Charge Ratio of Ultrahigh Energy Cosmic Rays

Simple and less hadronic-model-dependent method for cosmic-ray composition determination

Trinity: An Air-Shower Imaging System for the Detection of Ultrahigh Energy Neutrinos