Attention Competition with Advertisement

Uzay Cetin,Haluk O. Bingol

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.90.032801

2014-08-07

Abstract:In the new digital age, information is available in large quantities. Since information consumes primarily the attention of its recipients, the scarcity of attention is becoming the main limiting factor. In this study, we investigate the impact of advertisement pressure on a cultural market where consumers have a limited attention capacity. A model of competition for attention is developed and investigated analytically and by simulation. Advertisement is found to be much more effective when attention capacity of agents is extremely scarce. We have observed that the market share of the advertised item improves if dummy items are introduced to the market while the strength of the advertisement is kept constant.

Social and Information Networks,Adaptation and Self-Organizing Systems,Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the issue of the impact of advertising on the market in the digital age, when consumer attention has become a scarce resource due to information overload. Specifically, the researchers developed an attention - competition model and used analytical and simulation methods to explore how advertising pressure affects the market share of products in a market with limited attention capacity. The study specifically focuses on whether the effectiveness of advertising will be significantly enhanced when consumer attention is extremely scarce. In addition, the paper also explores the impact of introducing virtual products on the market share of the promoted products while maintaining the advertising intensity unchanged.

### Core issues of the paper
1. **When will the advertising mechanism surpass the recommendation process?**
- By expanding the simple recommendation model (SRM) and introducing advertising pressure as a new dynamic factor, the researchers explored the competitive relationship between the advertising mechanism and the recommendation process under different conditions.

2. **How much advertising is required to obtain a certain market share?**
- Through analysis and simulation, the researchers attempted to determine the specific impact of advertising on market share under different attention capacities and advertising intensities.

### Main findings
- **Advertising is more effective when attention is extremely scarce**:
- When the consumer's attention capacity is very limited, even weak advertising can significantly increase the market share of the promoted product. This phenomenon has been rigorously proven mathematically and verified in simulation experiments.

- **Introducing virtual products can increase the market share of the promoted product**:
- While maintaining the advertising intensity unchanged, introducing virtual products (i.e., products without actual value) into the market can increase the market share of the promoted product. This finding may have important implications for fields such as political propaganda and public management.

### Models and methods
- **Extended simple recommendation model (SRMwA)**:
- The original SRM model only considered the recommendation process, while the SRMwA model introduced advertising pressure on this basis, forming a more complex competition model.

- **Analytical methods**:
- Markov chains and epidemic models (such as the SIS model) were used to analyze the steady - state distribution of the system, thereby predicting the market share of the promoted product.

- **Simulation methods**:
- Through computer simulation, the accuracy of the analysis results was verified, and the system behavior under different parameter settings was further explored.

### Conclusions
- **The importance of advertising in attention - scarce markets**:
- Advertising has a significant effect in markets with extremely scarce attention, and can effectively increase market share even with a weak advertising intensity.

- **The strategic significance of introducing virtual products**:
- While maintaining the advertising intensity unchanged, introducing virtual products can be a strategy to increase the market share of the promoted product, and this finding has important implications for fields such as political propaganda and public management.

In summary, through theoretical analysis and empirical simulation, this paper reveals the important role of advertising in the attention economy and proposes some new market strategies, providing valuable insights for understanding and dealing with attention competition in modern markets.