Abstract:Neuronal activity is organized in collective patterns that are critical for information coding, generation, and communication between brain areas. These patterns are often described in terms of synchrony, oscillations, and phase relationships. Many methods have been proposed for the quantification of these collective states of dynamic neuronal organization. However, it is difficult to determine which method is best suited for which experimental setting and research question. This choice is further complicated by the fact that most methods are sensitive to a combination of synchrony, oscillations, and other factors; in addition, some of them display systematic biases that can complicate their interpretation. To address these challenges, we adopt a highly comparative approach, whereby spike trains are represented by a diverse library of measures. This enables unsupervised or supervised classification in the space of measures, or in that of spike trains. We compile a battery of 122 measures of synchrony, oscillations, and phase relationships, complemented with 9 measures of spiking intensity and variability. We first apply them to sets of synthetic spike trains with known statistical properties, and show that all measures are confounded by extraneous factors such as firing rate or population frequency, but to different extents. Then, we analyze spike trains recorded in different species–rat, mouse, and monkey–and brain areas– primary sensory cortices and hippocampus–and show that our highly comparative approach provides a high-dimensional quantification of collective network activity that can be leveraged for both unsupervised and supervised classification of firing patterns. Overall, the highly comparative approach provides a detailed description of the empirical properties of multineuron spike train analysis methods, including practical guidelines for their use in experimental settings, and advances our understanding of neuronal coordination and coding.

Monitoring spike train synchrony

Time-resolved and time-scale adaptive measures of spike train synchrony

Measuring multiple spike train synchrony

SPIKY: A graphical user interface for monitoring spike train synchrony

Automatic EEG-based Spike Ripples Detection with Multi-band Frequency Analysis

STSimM: A new tool for evaluating neuron model performance and detecting spike trains similarity

Spike Train SIMilarity Space (SSIMS): A Framework for Single Neuron and Ensemble Data Analysis

A New Method for Multiple Spike Train Analysis Based on Information Discrepancy

Event synchronization: A simple and fast method to measure synchronicity and time delay patterns

Synchrony, oscillations, and phase relationships in collective neuronal activity: a highly comparative overview of methods

Unbiased and robust quantification of synchronization between spikes and local field potential

Spike Trains Synchrony With Changed Neuronal Networks Parameters In A Hippocampus Ca3 Small-World Network Model

Spike synchrony as a measure of Gestalt structure

Cortical Spike Synchrony as a Measure of Input Familiarity

Assessment of synchrony in multiple neural spike trains using loglinear point process models

Detection and Removal of Hyper-synchronous Artifacts in Massively Parallel Spike Recordings

Discovering the Multi-neuronal Firing Patterns Based on a New Binless Spike Trains Measure.

Decoding Spike Train Ensembles: Tracking a Moving Stimulus

Improved Spike Detection Algorithm Based on Multi-Template Matching and Feature Extraction

Topological Clustering of Synchronous Spike Trains.

A new framework for Euclidean summary statistics in the neural spike train space