Throughflow centrality is a global indicator of the functional importance of species in ecosystems

Stuart R. Borrett

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2013.03.014

2012-09-05

Abstract:To better understand and manage complex systems like ecosystems it is critical to know the relative contribution of system components to system functioning. Ecologists and social scientists have described many ways that individuals can be important; This paper makes two key contributions to this research area. First, it shows that throughflow, the total energy-matter entering or exiting a system component, is a global indicator of the relative contribution of the component to the whole system activity. It is global because it includes the direct and indirect exchanges among community members. Further, throughflow is a special case of Hubbell status as defined in social science. This recognition effectively joins the concepts, enabling ecologists to use and build on the broader centrality research in network science. Second, I characterize the distribution of throughflow in 45 empirically-based trophic ecosystem models. Consistent with expectations, this analysis shows that a small fraction of the system components are responsible for the majority of the system activity. In 73% of the ecosystem models, 20% or less of the nodes generate 80% or more of the total system throughflow. Four or fewer dominant nodes are required to account for 50% of the total system activity. 121 of the 130 dominant nodes in the 45 ecosystem models could be classified as primary producers, dead organic matter, or bacteria. Thus, throughflow centrality indicates the rank power of the ecosystems components and shows the power concentration in the primary production and decomposition cycle. Although these results are specific to ecosystems, these techniques build on flow analysis based on economic input-output analysis. Therefore these results should be useful for ecosystem ecology, industrial ecology, the study of urban metabolism, as well as other domains using input-output analysis.

Quantitative Methods,Physics and Society,Populations and Evolution

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to identify the key components of functional importance in the ecosystem, and proposes a new centrality index - Throughflow Centrality (\(T_j\)) to assess the functional importance of each component in the ecosystem. Specifically, the paper has two main contributions:

1. **Proposing through - flow as a global index**: The paper points out that through - flow (\(T_j\)), that is, the total energy or material flow in and out of system components, is a global index for evaluating the relative contribution of system components to the overall system activity. This index includes not only direct exchanges but also indirect exchanges among community members. In addition, through - flow is a special case of Hubbell status or centrality defined in sociology. This recognition effectively links ecology with centrality research in network science, enabling ecologists to utilize and expand the broader centrality research results.

2. **Analyzing the distribution of through - flow in ecosystem models**: The paper analyzed the through - flow centrality of 45 empirical - based trophic ecosystem models. The results show that most of the system activity is accounted for by a small fraction of system components. Specifically, in 73% of the ecosystem models, 20% or fewer nodes generate more than 80% of the total system through - flow. Usually, only 4 or fewer nodes are required to explain 50% of the total system activity, and these nodes are defined as "community - dominant". Among the 45 ecosystem models, 122 out of 130 dominant nodes can be classified as primary producers, dead organic matter, or bacteria. This indicates that through - flow centrality reveals the functional importance of ecosystem components and shows the concentration of power in the primary production and decomposition cycles.

By solving these problems, the paper provides new perspectives and tools for understanding the structure and function of complex systems, especially for fields such as ecosystem ecology, industrial ecology, and urban metabolism research.