Abstract:For decades, a major underlying assumption behind theories of sentence comprehension has been that the parser only entertains analyses that are grammatically consistent with all words encountered in the sentence so far. A dramatic challenge to this self-consistency assumption came from two self-paced reading experiments in English (Tabor et al. 2004). Using a syntactic and a syntactic–semantic manipulation, Tabor et al. (2004) found that participants read a string of words more slowly if the string could locally form a grammatical structure that is un grammatical given the preceding words. In the years since, such local coherence effects, and in particular syntactic local coherence effects, have generated much debate about the nature of human sentence parsing, and have become a central explanandum for psycholinguistic theories. Despite this attention, to our knowledge no one has directly attempted to replicate the claimed effects. Here, we present a large-sample replication attempt using the original Tabor et al. (2004) syntactic and syntactic–semantic local coherence design using two methods (self-paced reading and bidirectional self-paced reading). A Bayes factor analysis shows evidence against a large, immediate effect of syntactic local coherence in reading, and only anecdotal evidence for a syntactic–semantic local coherence effect, but only in bidirectional self-paced reading. In this paradigm, there are also large effects of local coherence on rereading, which may be due to error recovery mechanisms, and which do not affect all participants. Our results suggest that the original effect sizes, especially for the much-debated early syntactic local coherence effect, are likely to be overestimates due to low power in the original Tabor et al. (2004) study. An important implication for psycholinguistic theory is that the challenge to self-consistency posed by local coherence effects is not as strong as previously believed.

The influence of referential processing on sentence complexity

Rule-Based and Word-Level Statistics-Based Processing of Language: Insights from Neuroscience

The properties of rare and complex syntactic constructions in English. A corpus-based comparative study

A Corpus-Based Analysis of the Effect of Syntactic Complexity on Disfluency in Consecutive Interpreting

Effects of Syntactic Distance and Word Order on Language Processing: an Investigation Based on a Psycholinguistic Treebank of English

Syntactic Complexity Development in the Writings of EFL Learners: Insights from a Dependency Syntactically-Annotated Corpus

Can Familiarity Lessen the Effect of Locality? A Case Study of Mandarin Chinese Subjects and the Following Adverbials

The effects of sentence length on dependency distance, dependency direction and the implications–Based on a parallel English–Chinese dependency treebank

Individual Differences in Holistic and Compositional Language Processing

Coordination and Referential Dependencies: a Dependency Grammar Account in Terms of Predicate-Valent Structures

Dependency Distance As A Metric of Language Comprehension Difficulty

Syntactic Complexity of Different Text Types: from the Perspective of Dependency Distance Both Linearly and Hierarchically

Referential context and executive functioning influence children's resolution of syntactic ambiguity

Category Locality Theory: A unified account of locality effects in sentence comprehension

The Interplay Between Referential Processing and Local Syntactic/semantic Processing: ERPs to Written Chinese Discourse.

Do local coherence effects exist in English reduced relative clauses?

Discourse comprehension and referential processing: effects of contextual distance and semantic plausibility on presupposition processing

Incremental Discourse-Update Constrains Number Agreement Attraction Effect

Does formal complexity reflect cognitive complexity? Investigating aspects of the Chomsky Hierarchy in an artificial language learning study

Neurophysiology of Hungarian subject-verb dependencies with varying intervening complexity

Minimization of dependency length in written English