Abstract:Memory consistency model (MCM) issues in out-of-order-issue microprocessor-based shared-memory systems are notoriously non-intuitive and a source of hardware design bugs. Prior hardware verification work is limited to in-order-issue processors, to proving the correctness only of some test cases, or to bounded verification that does not scale in practice beyond 7 instructions across all threads. Because cache coherence (i.e., write serialization and atomicity) and pipeline front-end verification and testing are well-studied, we focus on the memory ordering in an out-of-order-issue processor's load-store queue and the coherence interface between the core and global coherence. We propose QED based on the key notion of observability that any hardware reordering matters only if a forbidden value is produced. We argue that one needs to consider (1) only directly-ordered instruction pairs -- transitively non-redundant pairs connected by an edge in the MCM-imposed partial order -- and not all in-flight instructions, and (2) only the ordering of external events from other cores (e.g.,invalidations) but not the events' originating cores, achieving verification scalability in both the numbers of in-flight memory instructions and of cores. Exhaustively considering all pairs of instruction types and all types of external events intervening between each pair, QED attempts to restore any reordered instructions to an MCM-complaint order without changing the execution values, where failure indicates an MCM violation. Each instruction pair's exploration results in a decision tree of simple, narrowly-defined predicates to be evaluated against the RTL. In our experiments, we automatically generate the decision trees for SC, TSO, and RISC-V WMO, and illustrate automatable verification by evaluating a substantial predicate against BOOMv3 implementation of RISC-V WMO, leaving full automation to future work.

Software Verification for Weak Memory via Program Transformation

Fast Verification of Memory Consistency for Chip Multi-Processor

Lifting the Reasoning Level in Generic Weak Memory Verification (Extended Version)

Runtime Verification Based on Multi-thread Monitor

Verifying Optimizations of Concurrent Programs in the Promising Semantics

Weak Memory Demands Model-based Compiler Testing

QED: Scalable Verification of Hardware Memory Consistency

Memory Consistency and Program Transformations

Verifying C11-Style Weak Memory Libraries

On the Verification of Strong Atomicity in Programs Using STM.

Scalable Verification Framework for C Program

Practical Rely/Guarantee Verification of an Efficient Lock for seL4 on Multicore Architectures

RealityCheck: Bringing Modularity, Hierarchy, and Abstraction to Automated Microarchitectural Memory Consistency Verification

VSync: Push-Button Verification and Optimization for Synchronization Primitives on Weak Memory Models

SNIP: Speculative Execution and Non-Interference Preservation for Compiler Transformations

VSync: Push-Button Verification and Optimization for Synchronization Primitives on Weak Memory Models (Technical Report)

Automatic Verification of Embedded System Code Manipulating Dynamic Structures Stored in Contiguous Regions.

How Hard is Weak-Memory Testing?

Parameterized Design and Formal Verification of Multi-ported Memory

Overcoming Memory Weakness with Unified Fairness

What Cannot Be Implemented on Weak Memory?