Nanotube bundles and tube-tube orientation: A van der Waals Density Functional Study

Heiko Dumlich,Stephanie Reich
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.84.064121
2012-07-19
Abstract:We study the binding energy, intertube distance and electronic structure of bundles consisting of single walled carbon nanotubes of the same chirality. We model various nanotube structures (chiralities) and orientations with van der Waals density functional theory. The orientation of the tubes in the bundle strongly influences the properties of the bundles if the chirality of the tubes shares symmetry with the trigonal bundle structure, meaning chiralities which have a $60^\circ$-rotational symmetry (C$_6$-axis), e.g. ($12,0$) bundles. The bundle structure breaks the symmetry depending on the arrangement of the neighboring tubes. Pseudogaps open in the electronic density of states and intertube distances ($\pm5$-10%) vary in dependence of the relative orientation of the tubes in the bundle. Bundles of C$_6$-axis armchair tubes have metallic configurations. A $15^\circ$ rotation off the high symmetry configuration (AA-stacked) of a ($6,6$) bundle shows metallic behavior and has higher binding energy than the high symmetry configuration. We find binding energies between $19 meV/atom$ and $35 meV/atom$, depending on the chirality of the tubes. The intertube distances are between $3.2 Å$ and $3.4 Å$ but independent of orientation for non C$_6$-axis tubes.
Materials Science,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how the binding energy, inter - tube distance and electronic structure among single - walled carbon nanotubes in carbon nanotube bundles are affected by the chirality and orientation of nanotubes. Specifically, the research focuses on single - walled carbon nanotube bundles with the same chirality. The nanotube structures with different chiralities and orientations are simulated by van der Waals Density Functional (vdW - DF) to explore how these factors affect the properties of nanotube bundles. ### Main problem points: 1. **Binding energy and inter - tube distance**: Study the binding energy and inter - tube distance of nanotube bundles with different chiralities and orientations, especially how these properties change when the chirality of nanotubes matches the three - fold symmetry (C6 axis). 2. **Electronic structure**: Explore the electronic structure of nanotube bundles, especially whether there is a pseudogap near the Fermi level and how these pseudogaps change with the change of nanotube orientation. 3. **Rotational energy barrier**: Analyze the rotational energy barrier of nanotubes in the bundle, especially for nanotubes with C6 - axis symmetry, and how these energy barriers affect the properties of nanotube bundles. ### Research background: - **Properties of carbon nanotubes**: The properties of carbon nanotubes depend on their one - dimensionality and the specific arrangement of surface carbon atoms (chirality). Nanotubes usually exist in the form of bundles, ropes or fibers, and these three - dimensional structures are formed by van der Waals interactions between nanotube surfaces. - **Theoretical and experimental research**: Although there have been some theoretical and experimental studies on the mechanical and electronic properties of nanotube bundles, little is known about the influence of chirality on the electronic structure of nanotube bundles. In particular, monochiral bundles have not been successfully prepared in experiments yet, but it is expected to be achieved in the future. ### Research methods: - **Calculation method**: Use the SIESTA software package to perform density functional theory (DFT) calculations, optimize the geometric structure of isolated nanotubes, and use the van der Waals density functional developed by Dion et al. to calculate the properties of nanotube bundles. - **Model**: By placing a nanotube in a hexagonal unit cell, an infinite number of nanotubes (bulk - bundle) are simulated, which is used as a model for an internal nanotube in an actual carbon nanotube bundle. ### Main findings: - **Chirality - dependence**: For nanotubes with C6 - axis symmetry, their properties (such as binding energy and inter - tube distance) strongly depend on the orientation of nanotubes in the bundle. For example, (6, 6) and (12, 0) nanotubes show metallicity in some orientations and pseudogaps in other orientations. - **Rotational energy barrier**: There are significant energy barriers when nanotubes with C6 - axis symmetry rotate in the bundle, and these energy barriers can be as high as 10.5 meV/atom. For nanotubes without three - fold symmetry, the rotational energy barrier is less than 0.3 meV/atom. - **Electronic structure**: The electronic structure near the Fermi level changes with the change of nanotube orientation. Pseudogaps appear in some orientations, while metallicity is maintained in others. ### Conclusions: - **Monochiral nanotube bundles**: The properties of monochiral nanotube bundles (especially binding energy and inter - tube distance) are very sensitive to chiral symmetry and the orientation of nanotubes in the bundle. These findings are of great significance for the future preparation and application of monochiral nanotube bundles. - **Mixed - chiral nanotube bundles**: For nanotube bundles containing multiple chiralities, their properties are less sensitive to the symmetry breaking caused by chirality mismatch, so the dependence of these bundles' properties on chiral orientation is weaker. Through these studies, the author provides an important theoretical basis for understanding the properties of nanotube bundles, especially for guiding the application of monochiral nanotube bundles that may be prepared in the future.