Short Circuits in Thermally Ionized Plasmas: A Mechanism for Intermittent Heating of Protoplanetary Disks

Alexander Hubbard,Colin McNally,Mordecai-Mark Mac Low

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/761/1/58

2012-10-23

Abstract:Many astrophysical systems of interest, including protoplanetary accretion disks, are made of turbu- lent magnetized gas with near solar metallicity. Thermal ionization of alkali metals in such gas exceeds non-thermal ionization when temperatures climb above roughly 1000 K. As a result, the conductiv- ity, proportional to the ionization fraction, gains a strong, positive dependence on temperature. In this paper, we demonstrate that this relation between the temperature and the conductivity triggers an exponential instability that acts similarly to an electrical short, where the increased conductivity concentrates the current and locally increases the Ohmic heating. This contrasts with the resistiv- ity increase expected in an ideal magnetic reconnection region. The instability acts to focus narrow current sheets into even narrower sheets with far higher currents and temparatures. We lay out the basic principles of this behavior in this paper using protoplanetary disks as our example host system, motivated by observations of chondritic meteorites and their ancestors, dust grains in protoplanetary disks, that reveal the existence of strong, frequent heating events that this instability could explain.

Earth and Planetary Astrophysics,Solar and Stellar Astrophysics,Plasma Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to generate intermittent high - temperature heating events in protoplanetary disks. Specifically, the author explored a new instability mechanism. When the temperature exceeds approximately 1000 K, the thermal ionization of alkali metals causes a sharp increase in electrical conductivity, thus triggering a phenomenon similar to a short - circuit in an electrical circuit. This phenomenon will lead to current concentration, locally enhanced Ohmic heating, and the formation of narrow current sheets with higher currents, thereby explaining the formation conditions of high - temperature minerals such as chondrules and crystalline silicates observed in protoplanetary disks.

### Main research background
- **Protoplanetary disks**: These disk - like structures surround young stars and are the sites of planet formation. The matter in the disks is mainly composed of gas and dust, with a metallicity approximately similar to that of the Sun.
- **Thermal ionization**: When the temperature exceeds about 1000 K, the thermal ionization of alkali metals (such as potassium) becomes the main source of free electrons. This results in a positive correlation between electrical conductivity and temperature.
- **Observational evidence**: Through the study of chondrite and comet samples, scientists have found that these celestial bodies contain minerals that solidified after melting, indicating that they experienced a rapid high - temperature heating process during their formation.

### Research motivation
- **Formation of high - temperature minerals**: The existence of high - temperature minerals (such as chondrules and crystalline silicates) in protoplanetary disks requires intermittent high - temperature heating events to be explained.
- **Limitations of traditional mechanisms**: The classical magnetic reconnection mechanism cannot fully explain the frequency and intensity of these high - temperature events.

### Research methods
- **Theoretical analysis**: The author derived a new instability mechanism by analyzing the magnetohydrodynamic equations, especially considering the situation where the resistivity changes with temperature.
- **Numerical simulation**: Using a one - dimensional numerical code, the development process of this instability was simulated to verify the theoretical prediction.

### Main conclusions
- **Discovery of a new mechanism**: When the temperature exceeds 1000 K, the thermal ionization of alkali metals causes a sharp increase in electrical conductivity, triggering an exponential instability, similar to the short - circuit phenomenon in an electrical circuit.
- **Local heating**: This instability leads to current concentration, locally enhanced Ohmic heating, and the formation of narrow current sheets with higher currents, thus explaining the formation conditions of high - temperature minerals in protoplanetary disks.
- **Difference from the classical mechanism**: This mechanism is different from the classical magnetic reconnection mechanism. The latter usually assumes that the resistivity increases in the reconnection region, while the new mechanism leads to a decrease in resistivity and current concentration.

### Formula summary
- **Change of resistivity with temperature**:
\[
\frac{\partial \eta}{\partial T}\bigg|_{T_0}=-\frac{\eta_0}{T_1}
\]
where the \(T_1\) parameterizes the sensitivity of resistivity to the temperature gradient.

- **Ohmic heating time**:
\[
t_h = \frac{4\pi n n k_B T_0}{(\gamma - 1)\eta_0 J_0^2}
\]

- **Linear stability analysis**:
\[
\lambda^2+\lambda\left(\frac{1}{t_r}+\frac{1}{t_b}+\frac{1}{t_{\eta}'}\right)+\frac{1}{t_r}\left(\frac{1}{t_b}-\frac{1}{t_{\eta}'}\right)=0
\]
where \(t_r\) is the resistive time of the perturbation, \(t_b\) is the cooling time, and \(t_{\eta}'\) is the resistivity heating time.

- **Growth rate in the non - linear stage**:
\[
\frac{1}{t_c}=\frac{1}{2t_{r,c}}\left\{-\left(1+\frac{2T_i}{T(\gamma - 1)\beta_c}\right)+\left[1+\frac{12T_i}{T(\gamma - 1)\beta_c}+\left(\frac{2T_i}{T(\gamma - 1)}\right)\right]\right\}