Shunji Tsuchiya,R. Ganesh,Arun Paramekanti
Abstract:Motivated by recent experiments on atomic Dirac fermions in a tunable honeycomb optical lattice, we study the attractive Hubbard model of superfluidity in the anisotropic honeycomb lattice. At weak-coupling, we find that the maximum mean field pairing transition temperature, as a function of density and interaction strength, occurs for the case with isotropic hopping amplitudes. In this isotropic case, we go beyond mean field theory and study collective fluctuations, treating both pairing and density fluctuations for interaction strengths ranging from weak to strong coupling. We find evidence for a sharp sound mode, together with a well-defined Leggett mode over a wide region of the phase diagram. We also calculate the superfluid order parameter and collective modes in the presence of nonzero superfluid flow. The flow-induced softening of these collective modes leads to dynamical instabilities involving stripe-like density modulations as well as a Leggett-mode instability associated with the natural sublattice symmetry breaking charge-ordered state on the honeycomb lattice. The latter provides a non-trivial test for the experimental realization of the one-band Hubbard model. We delineate regimes of the phase diagram where the critical current is limited by depairing or by such collective instabilities, and discuss experimental implications of our results.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to study the superfluid properties of Dirac fermions in tunable honeycomb lattices. Specifically, the authors explored the superfluid behavior of the attractive Hubbard model in anisotropic honeycomb lattices. In particular, under weak - coupling conditions, they studied the maximum value of the pairing transition temperature through the mean - field theory, as well as the collective fluctuations in isotropic conditions, including pairing and density fluctuations. In addition, they analyzed the superfluid order parameter and collective modes in the non - zero superfluid case, and explored how the softening caused by these modes with flow leads to dynamic instabilities, especially the Leggett - mode instability related to the striped - density modulation and the charge - ordered state resulting from the natural sub - lattice symmetry breaking of the honeycomb lattice. These studies provide important testing means for the experimental realization of the one - dimensional Hubbard model, and the experimental significance of the results is also discussed.
### Main problems and research methods
1. **Research background**:
- Ultracold atoms in optical lattices are an important platform for studying strongly - correlated quantum matter states, such as superconductivity and magnetism.
- Recent experimental progress has inspired interest in optical lattices with tunable honeycomb structures, especially in the field of graphene research.
- The paper focuses on the superfluid properties of the attractive Hubbard model on two - dimensional honeycomb lattices.
2. **Research objectives**:
- To study the variation of the maximum mean - field pairing transition temperature (\(T_0^c\)) with fermion density and interaction strength in anisotropic honeycomb lattices under weak - coupling conditions.
- To study the collective modes in the superfluid, including density and phase fluctuations, in isotropic conditions.
- To analyze the changes in the superfluid order parameter and collective modes in the non - zero superfluid case, and how these changes lead to dynamic instabilities.
3. **Main findings**:
- Under weak - coupling conditions, the maximum \(T_0^c\) occurs in the case of isotropic transition amplitudes.
- In isotropic conditions, clear Anderson - Bogoliubov (AB) sound modes and extensive Leggett modes are found.
- In the non - zero superfluid case, the superfluid phase becomes unstable, probably due to depairing or collective charge - modulation instabilities.
- The superfluid is most stable against depairing instability near specific fillings (such as \(n = 3/4\) or \(n = 5/4\)), but a gapless superfluid state also appears in these regions.
4. **Experimental significance**:
- It provides a testing means for experimentally verifying the applicability of the one - dimensional Hubbard model, especially by studying the collective - mode spectrum through Bragg scattering experiments.
- It explores the situation where the critical current is limited by depairing or collective instabilities under different densities and interaction strengths.
### Formula summary
- **Mean - field equations**:
\[
\frac{1}{U}=\frac{1}{N}\sum_{k}\sum_{\tau = \pm}\frac{\tanh(\beta E_{\tau}(k)/2)}{2E_{\tau}(k)}
\]
\[
n = 1-\frac{1}{N}\sum_{k}\sum_{\tau = \pm}\frac{\xi_{\tau}^k}{E_{\tau}(k)}\tanh(\beta E_{\tau}(k)/2)
\]
where \(\xi_{\tau}^k=\pm|\gamma_k|-\mu\), \(E_{\tau}(k)=\sqrt{(\xi_{\tau}^k)^2+\Delta_0^2}\), and \(N = 2M\) is the number of lattice points, and \(M\) is the number of unit cells.
- **Momentum - space single - particle Hamiltonian**:
\[
H=\sum_{k,\sigma}(\gamma_k c_{k,a,\sigma}^{\dagger}c_{k,b,\sigma}+\gamma_k^* c_{k,b,\sigma}^{\dagger}c_{k,a,\sigma})
\]