Comment on "Compositional and Microchemical Evidence of Piezonuclear Fission Reactions in Rock Specimens Subjected to Compression Tests" [Strain 47 (Suppl. 2), 282 (2011)]

G. Amato,G. Bertotti,O. Bottauscio,G. Crotti,F. Fiorillo,G. Mana,M. L. Rastello,P. Tavella,F. Vinai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1205.6418

2012-05-30

Abstract:It is shown that the chemical composition data published by Carpinteri et al. in the article "Compositional and Microchemical Evidence of Piezonuclear Fission Reactions in Rock Specimens Subjected to Compression Tests" [Strain 47 (Suppl. 2), 282 (2011)] cannot be the result of independent measurements as claimed by the authors. Therefore, no conclusion can be drawn from them about compositional modifications induced in the stone by hypothetical piezonuclear reactions taking place during catastrophic failure of the material at fracture.

Materials Science,Geophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to verify the hypothesis proposed by Carpinteri et al. in previous studies, that is, whether the assumed piezonuclear fission reactions that occur when rock samples are subjected to compression tests will lead to significant changes in the sample composition. Specifically, Carpinteri et al. claimed that through energy - dispersive X - ray spectroscopy (EDS) analysis, it was found that during the rock fracture process, iron (Fe) atoms may be transformed into lighter elements (such as aluminum Al), and lead to compositional changes.

### Main problems and conclusions of the paper

1. **Questioning data independence**:
- Amato et al. pointed out that the chemical composition data (see Tables I and II) provided by Carpinteri et al. cannot be regarded as the results of independent measurements. These data show abnormal regularity and correlation, which is extremely unlikely to occur in actual independent measurements.

2. **Data analysis**:
- By re - ordering and carefully examining 60 EDS spectral data, Amato et al. found that there is a high degree of correlation among most data sets. For example, Tables III, IV and V show that multiple data sets have almost exactly the same composition ratios at different measurement points, and this consistency far exceeds the normal measurement error range.
- Specifically, the contents of certain oxides (such as Si, Mg, K) are exactly the same to two decimal places in multiple data sets, which is almost impossible in random independent measurements. According to statistical analysis, the probability of such consistency is very low (about \(10^{-9}\)), so it can be concluded that these data are not obtained independently.

3. **Conclusion**:
- Due to the lack of data independence, Amato et al. concluded that no valid conclusions can be drawn from these data regarding any compositional changes in rock samples caused by piezonuclear fission reactions during the fracture process. In other words, the experimental results of Carpinteri et al. are not scientifically reliable and cannot support their hypothesis about piezonuclear fission reactions.

### Summary
The core issue of this review article is to question and refute the conclusion of Carpinteri et al. regarding compositional changes in rock samples caused by piezonuclear fission reactions during compression tests. Through detailed statistical analysis, Amato et al. have proven that the original data has a serious non - independence problem, thus negating the validity of this hypothesis.