Balancing the trade-off between data center development and its environmental impacts: A comparative analysis of Data Center Policymaking in Singapore, Netherlands, Ireland, Germany, USA, and the UK

Ian Varela Soares,Masaru Yarime,Magdalena Klemun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2024.103769

IF: 6.424

2024-05-01

Environmental Science & Policy

Abstract:Data center's deployment rate has raised concerns about high natural resource consumption. The scholarship has examined the scale of negative environmental impacts but focused to a lesser degree on policy responses enacted to improve data center sustainability. We analyze these policy responses in terms of (i) the degree of policy change undertaken, (ii) the duration of policy changes, and (iii) the effects on data center deployment rates. This work investigates six data center hubs - Singapore, Netherlands(Amsterdam), Ireland, Germany(Frankfurt), USA(Virginia), and the UK(London) – identifying three policy responses: moratorium, adjustment, and continuation. All six locations changed their data center deployment strategies. In three cases, data center policy adjustments were preceded by significant short-term disruptions of digital infrastructure growth (e.g., halts to new permits), demonstrating the challenges in managing high-growth sectors under environmental and infrastructural constraints Among the three cases, only two have introduced long-term measures, i.e., adjustments through stricter environmental standards, showing that moratoriums better work as a temporary measure to stabilize natural resource consumption while buying time for long-term adjustments. Conversely, in the two cases opting for a continuation of data center deployment (e.g., redirecting new permits to less resource-constrained areas), the strategy lowered implementation costs but has been subject to a lingering opposition process. Beyond response specificities, the six cases also present general policymaking patterns. First, stricter energy accuracy standards may facilitate planning sustainable data center growth. Second, policy responses may yield better results when paired with multi-regional infrastructural strategies matching IT infrastructure needs with available energy capacity.

environmental sciences