Non-invasive ventilation versus high-flow nasal cannula oxygen therapy with apnoeic oxygenation for preoxygenation before intubation of patients with acute hypoxaemic respiratory failure: a randomised, multicentre, open-label trial
Jean-Pierre Frat,Jean-Damien Ricard,Jean-Pierre Quenot,Nicolas Pichon,Alexandre Demoule,Jean-Marie Forel,Jean-Paul Mira,Rémi Coudroy,Guillaume Berquier,Benoit Voisin,Gwenhaël Colin,Bertrand Pons,Pierre Eric Danin,Jérome Devaquet,Gwenael Prat,Raphaël Clere-Jehl,Franck Petitpas,Emmanuel Vivier,Keyvan Razazi,Mai-Anh Nay,Vincent Souday,Jean Dellamonica,Laurent Argaud,Stephan Ehrmann,Aude Gibelin,Christophe Girault,Pascal Andreu,Philippe Vignon,Laurence Dangers,Stéphanie Ragot,Arnaud W Thille,FLORALI-2 study group,REVA network,Delphine Chatellier,Florence Boissier,Anne Veinstein,René Robert,Céline Deletage-Métreau,Morgane Olivry,Claire Dahyot-Fizelier,Auguste Dargent,Audrey Large,Emmanuelle Begot,Claire Mancia,Maxence Decavele,Martin Dres,Samuel Lehingue,Laurent Papazian,Marine Paul,Nathalie Marin,Matthieu Le Meur,Mohammed Laissy,Anaita Rouzé,Saad Nseir,Matthieu Henry-Lagarrigue,Aihem Yehia,Frédéric Martino,Charles Cerf,Pierre Bailly,Julie Helms,Jean Baptiste Putegnat,Armand Mekontso-Dessap,Thierry Boulain,Pierre Asfar,Séverin Cabasson,Florent Wallet,Kada Klouche,Frédéric Bellec
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S2213-2600(19)30048-7
Abstract:Background: Non-invasive ventilation has never been compared with high-flow oxygen to determine whether it reduces the risk of severe hypoxaemia during intubation. We aimed to determine if preoxygenation with non-invasive ventilation was more efficient than high-flow oxygen in reducing the risk of severe hypoxaemia during intubation. Methods: The FLORALI-2 multicentre, open-label trial was done in 28 intensive care units in France. Adult patients undergoing tracheal intubation for acute hypoxaemic respiratory failure (a partial pressure of arterial oxygen [PaO2] to fraction of inspired oxygen [FiO2] ratio of ≤300 mm Hg) were randomly assigned (1:1; block size, four participants) to non-invasive ventilation or high-flow oxygen during preoxygenation, with stratification by PaO2/FiO2 ratio (≤200 mm Hg vs >200 mm Hg). Key exclusion criteria were intubation for cardiac arrest, altered consciousness (defined as a Glasgow coma score of less than eight points), other contraindications to non-invasive ventilation (recent laryngeal, oesophageal, or gastric surgery, and substantial facial fractures), pulse oximetry not available, pregnant or breastfeeding women, and refusal to participate. The primary outcome was the occurrence of severe hypoxaemia (pulse oximetry <80%) during the procedure, assessed in the intention-to-treat population. This trial is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT02668458. Findings: Between April 15, 2016, and Jan 8, 2017, 2079 patients were intubated in the 28 participating units, and 322 were enrolled. We excluded five patients with no recorded data, two who withdrew consent or were under legal protection, one who was not intubated, and one who had a cardiac arrest. Of the 313 patients included in the intention-to-treat analysis, 142 were assigned to non-invasive ventilation and 171 to high-flow oxygen therapy. Severe hypoxaemia occurred in 33 (23%) of 142 patients after preoxygenation with non-invasive ventilation and 47 (27%) of 171 with high-flow oxygen (absolute difference -4·2%, 95% CI -13·7 to 5·5; p=0·39). In the 242 patients with moderate-to-severe hypoxaemia (PaO2/FiO2 ≤200 mm Hg), severe hypoxaemia occurred less frequently after preoxygenation with non-invasive ventilation than with high-flow oxygen (28 [24%] of 117 patients vs 44 [35%] of 125; adjusted odds ratio 0·56, 0·32 to 0·99, p=0·0459). Serious adverse events did not differ between treatment groups, with the most common immediate complications being systolic arterial hypotension (70 [49%] patients in the non-invasive ventilation group vs 86 [50%] patients in the high-flow oxygen group) and chest infiltrate on x-ray (28 [20%] vs 33 [19%]), and the most common late complications being death at day 28 (53 [37%] vs 58 [34%]) and ventilator-associated pneumonia during ICU stay (31 [22%] vs 35 [20%]). Interpretation: In patients with acute hypoxaemic respiratory failure, preoxygenation with non-invasive ventilation or high-flow oxygen therapy did not change the risk of severe hypoxaemia. Future research should explore the effect of preoxygenation method in patients with moderate-to-severe hypoxaemia at baseline. Funding: French Ministry of Health.