Music-supported Systematic Treatment Strategies for People with Executive Dysfunction Following Traumatic Brain Injury: Similarities and Divergencies in 7 Case Reports

Berit Marie Dykesteen Vik

Abstract:The present article explores in-depth, 7 case reports of patients with cognitive and social deficits following mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI). We sought similarities and divergencies which may have an impact of the final outcome of a music-supported intervention. The main question was to define the factors that might predict a positive or negative outcome for cognitive enhancement and improved social behavior after music-supported intervention for patients with cognitive and behavioral deficits following mTBI. This article is a cohort study, based on existing unpublished data from a recent study by Vik et al. [1] which describes how 8 weeks of structured piano-playing reorganized the functional neuronal networks of 7 patients with mTBI who evidenced significant enhanced cognitive performance. A case-study methodology is applied exploring behavioral data obtained from the study, that was not published. This methodology allows for an in-depth analysis of clinical data, inclusive of observational data during intervention and data from semi-structured interviews pre-post intervention, as well. 7 patients with executive dysfunction following mTBI participated in the music-based intervention. They were in a chronic phase and were either sicklisted or worked part-time. 6 out of 7 participants returned to work post-intervention. Results for analyses were taken from neurophysiological tests, fMRI and resting-state fMRI consolidated with enhanced cognitive performance and functional neuroplasticity in orbitofrontal cortex. These results were based on quantitative analysis with mean effect and did not give specific information about similarities and divergencies between the participants that may have had any impact on the final outcome. The aim of the present article is to broaden understanding of factors that may have an impact on a positive rehabilitation process for patients with cognitive and social deficits following mTBI. The results offer evidence that playing the piano, as described in the intervention protocol, may enhance executive functions. All patients achieved a significant increase of concentration and in their memorization capacity. However, in reference to social interaction, we identified two negative factors, namely pre-injury depression and pre-injury TBI. This is a replication of a well-known variables. These results may refine a systematic treatment strategy in support of music training to improve both cogntive and behavioral domains of functioning in patients following mTBI. I suggest that the successful intervention described (1) should implement a multidisciplinary program that would ideally accompany the music-supported intervention to catch patients that otherwise would be prone to negative outcomes.

Psychology,Medicine