Abstract:India’s cultural diversity is an illustration of sustainable engagement of people with their environment where cultural practices are in a delicate ecological balance often with meagre resources and harsh conditions. This balance is underestimated when programmes and services seek inspiration and guidance from global trends without adequate attention to local reality. Poverty is treated as a failure of the people (and by the people as a failure of the Government) rather than a consequence of long-standing structural marginalization. Blaming the victim has been an important theme in evaluating cultural practices of people living with disadvantage. This is a serious error in judgement both on scientific and ethical grounds. Despite enduring scholarly work that recognizes the need for context-sensitive theory and research in the field of psychology, institutional practices have remained largely loyal to global trends. Large-scale intervention programmes in community welfare persist with practices that derive directly from mainstream psychology, especially in the fields of education, family studies and child development. Through the financial and ideological push from international NGOs that prescribe objectives and strategies for intervention, the real problem remains ignored despite claiming impressive outreach. Primarily because of misplaced emphases and misconstrued priorities, intervention initiatives often fail to meet the objectives of social justice and equity. Furthermore, they may even result in distancing people in marginalized communities further, on account of unintended consequences of welfare activity. This can be seen in the large number of youth that hang precariously in between the world that they knew and the one that was implicitly promised to them. In spite of claims about coverage in terms of numbers, providing ecologically valid, cultural relevant and socially just services is restricted to a handful of committed agencies. This article will focus on specific instances of educational and welfare programmes that are advanced without either the knowledge about or respect for local community ideology in the desire to bring about social change for their “upliftment”. A special case in point is the persistent inability for the poor to access and participate in good quality education despite their enthusiasm and motivation. After providing an overview of the ideological mismatch between local culture and global policy, I will also give examples of experiments that have been successful in working towards ethically and scientifically sound welfare initiatives.

Indian children and tribal group homes: new interpretations of the Whipper Man

Children of Tribal Unwed Mothers and Their Non-Legitimate Origin: A Social Exclusion Perspective

"How can our children learn from us about our way of life or understand who they are?": Residential schools and their impact on the wellbeing of Indigenous youth in Attapadi, South India

SOCIAL WORK MAKING REPATRIATION A REALITY: A CASE STUDY FROM THE STATE OF PUNJAB

From Boys Town to Oliver Twist. Separating fact from fiction in welfare reform and out-of-home placement of children and youth

What are Aboriginal children and young people in out‐of‐home care telling us? A review of the child voice literature to understanding perspectives and experiences of the statutory care system

Social services: the Navajo way

The Indian Adoption Project and the Profession of Social Work

Small Families Through Social Transformation. India.

Children's Social Interaction and Parental Attitudes Among Hupa Indians and Anglo-Americans

The Science and Ethics of Intervention Programmes in Family and Child Welfare: Towards Building an Inclusive Psychology for Social Justice

Attachment and the (mis)apprehension of Aboriginal children: epistemic violence in child welfare interventions

'They got my back': Thematic analysis of relationship building in nurse home visiting in Aboriginal communities

Beyond attachment theory: Indigenous perspectives on the child–caregiver bond from a northwest tribal community

Children in out-of-home care's right to family and cultural connection: Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander and non-Indigenous Australian children's perspectives

A community-embedded approach to increasing the health literacy of aboriginal children in a regional area: processes of co-design and local implementation

Honoring Tribal Spirituality in India: An Exploratory Study of Their Beliefs, Rituals and Healing Practices

The Power of Authenticity and Cultural Safety at the Intersection of Healthcare and Child Protection

Wapítat Ttáwaxt (Community in Service to Community): Results of Community Stakeholder Engagement into the Initial Development of a Tribally Adapted Interdependent Life Skills Curriculum for American Indian Teens

DISCOVERING FRUGAL INNOVATIONS THROUGH DELIVERING EARLY CHILDHOOD HOME-VISITING INTERVENTIONS IN LOW-RESOURCE TRIBAL COMMUNITIES

Formative Research and Cultural Tailoring of a Substance Abuse Prevention Program for American Indian Youth: Findings From the Intertribal Talking Circle Intervention