Universality of the Plastic Instability in Strained Amorphous Solids

Ratul Dasgupta,Smarajit Karmakar,Itamar Procaccia
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.108.075701
2011-11-03
Abstract:By comparing the response to external strains in metallic glasses and in Lenard-Jones glasses we find a quantitative universality of the fundamental plastic instabilities in the athermal, quasistatic limit. Microscopically these two types of glasses are as different as one can imagine, the latter being determined by binary interactions, whereas the former by multiple interactions due to the effect of the electron gas that cannot be disregarded. In spite of this enormous difference the plastic instability is the same saddle-node bifurcation. As a result the statistics of stress and energy drops in the elasto-plastic steady state are universal, sharing the same system-size exponents.
Soft Condensed Matter
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore and verify the universality of different types of amorphous solids (especially metallic glasses and Lennard - Jones glasses) in terms of plastic instabilities. Specifically, by comparing the responses of the two types of glasses under applied strain, the author aims to reveal the quantitative universality of their fundamental plastic instabilities in the athermal, quasi - static limit. Although, from a microscopic perspective, these two glass materials are very different - the former is dominated by many - body interactions, while the latter is mainly determined by two - body interactions, the study found that plastic instabilities are essentially the same saddle - node bifurcation. Therefore, whether in two - body or many - body interaction systems, the statistical properties of plastic instabilities (such as the statistics of stress and energy drops) exhibit the same system - size exponent, indicating the universal nature of plastic instabilities. The paper also mentions that the occurrence of this plastic instability is not due to pre - existing "weak" points or "shear transformation zones" in the material, but during the straining process, a local minimum of the system collides with a nearby saddle point, causing an eigenvalue of the Hessian matrix to approach zero. This process can be described by the change of the eigenvalue \(\lambda_P\) with the external strain \(\gamma\), and the relationship is: \[ \lambda_P \propto \sqrt{\gamma_P - \gamma} \] Furthermore, when the system reaches the yield transition and enters the elastic - plastic steady state, each plastic instability event is accompanied by drops in stress \(\Delta\sigma\) and potential energy \(\Delta U\). The long - term strain - averaged values of these drops vary with the system size \(N\) following specific power - law relationships: \[ \langle\Delta U\rangle \sim N^{\alpha}, \quad \langle\Delta\sigma\rangle \sim N^{\beta} \] where the exponents \(\alpha = 1/3\) and \(\beta = - 2/3\) are universal for all the studied two - body glasses and in two - and three - dimensional cases. The paper further shows that even under finite strain - rate and temperature conditions, up to approximately \(2/3\) of the glass - transition temperature \(T_g\), these fundamental plastic instability mechanisms still dominate the statistical properties of plastic events. In summary, the core issue of this paper is to explore and prove the universality of plastic instabilities in different types of amorphous solids, emphasizing that the essential characteristics of plastic instabilities are not affected by the details of microscopic interactions.