Adolescent relationship violence: Should pushes and hits always be considered violent?

Román Ronzón-Tirado,Marina J. Muñoz-Rivas,Jamie Nguyen,Renee McDonald,Ernest N. Jouriles
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1037/vio0000527
2024-08-30
Psychology of Violence
Abstract:Objective: Research on adolescent relationship violence often involves having adolescents report on physically forceful acts, such as pushes and hits, that have occurred in the context of dating relationships. The present study compares: (a) adolescents who reported having experienced acts of physical force by a dating partner and attributed it solely to playfulness (playful only); (b) those who reported having experienced such acts and attributed at least some to conflict, anger, or jealousy (violent); and (c) those who reported not having experienced acts of physical force in their dating relationships (no physical force). Adolescents were compared on anxiety, depression, relationship satisfaction, and psychological violence. Method: Adolescents ( n = 1,077) completed measures of anxiety, depression, relationship satisfaction, and psychological violence. Results: Adolescents in the playful-only group reported lower levels of anxiety and higher levels of relationship satisfaction, compared to adolescents in the violent group. Additionally, adolescents in the playful only group reported higher levels of depression than those in the no physical force group. Adolescents in the playful only group reported higher levels of psychological violence than those in the no physical force group and lower levels than those in the violent group. Conclusions: Adolescents who experienced physically forceful acts only in a playful context were not as distressed as those who experienced such acts in the context of conflict, anger, or jealousy; however, adolescents who experienced physically forceful acts only in a playful context still appear to be more distressed than those who do not experience physically forceful acts. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved)
psychology, clinical,family studies,criminology & penology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?