Low energy graphene edge termination via small diameter nanotube formation

Viktoria V. Ivanovskaya,Alberto Zobelli,Philipp Wagner,Malcolm I. Heggie,Patrick R. Briddon,Mark J. Rayson,Chris P. Ewels

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.065502

2011-07-05

Abstract:We demonstrate that free graphene sheet edges can curl back on themselves,reconstructing as nanotubes. This results in lower formation energies than any other non-functionalised edge structure reported to date in the literature. We determine the critical tube size and formation barrier and compare with density functional simulations of other edge terminations including a new reconstructed Klein edge. Simulated high resolution electron microscopy images show why such rolled edges may be difficult to detect. Rolled zigzag edges serve as metallic conduction channels, separated from the neighbouring bulk graphene by a chain of insulating sp$^3$-carbon atoms, and introduce Van Hove singularities into the graphene density of states.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the stability of the graphene edge structure and its electronic properties. Specifically, the authors explored how the edges of a free graphene sheet can stabilize themselves by curling to form nanotubes, and analyzed the energy advantages and electronic behavior of such structures. The following is a detailed interpretation:

### Research Background and Problems

1. **Instability of Graphene Edges**
- Free graphene edges are prone to chemical functionalization under environmental conditions due to the existence of dangling bonds, which leads to their instability.
- Under vacuum conditions, such as in an electron microscope column, unterminated edges can be observed, but these edges are still unstable.

2. **Limitations of Existing Edge Structures**
- Traditional edge structures include armchair edges, zigzag edges, and some reconstructed edge types (such as 5 - 7 reconstructed zigzag edges). However, there is still no consensus on the most stable free - edge structure.

3. **New Edge Stabilization Mechanism**
- The authors proposed a new edge stabilization mechanism: graphene edges can curl back on themselves and rebond to form nanotubes, thereby eliminating dangling bonds and achieving a more stable structure.

### Main Research Contents

1. **Energy Calculation and Comparison**
- Calculate the formation energies of different types of graphene edge structures, including traditional edge types and newly proposed nanotube - terminated edges, through density functional theory (DFT).
- Calculate the formation energies of nanotube - terminated edges with different diameters and compare them with free edges.

2. **Structural Features**
- Describe the atomic structure of nanotube - terminated edges, especially the sp³ hybridization of carbon atoms, which makes the edges more stable.
- Propose three new edge types: armchair nanotube - terminated edge, armchair - like nanotube - terminated edge, and zigzag nanotube - terminated edge.

3. **Electronic Properties**
- Analyze the influence of these new edge structures on the electronic properties of graphene, especially the introduction of Van Hove singularities and metallic conduction channels.
- Demonstrate the unique electronic behavior of these edge structures by calculating the density of states (DOS) and band structure.

4. **Experimental Verification and Simulation**
- Use high - resolution transmission electron microscope (HRTEM) simulation images to explain why these curled edges may be difficult to detect.
- Explore the observability and potential applications of these edge structures in actual experiments.

### Conclusions

The authors proved through theoretical calculations and simulations that nanotube - terminated edges formed by curling are more stable than other known non - functionalized edge structures. This structure not only eliminates dangling bonds but also introduces unique electronic properties, such as metallic conduction channels and Van Hove singularities. In addition, the authors also discussed the difficulty of observing these edge structures in actual experiments and their potential application prospects.

In summary, this paper solves the problem of the stability of the graphene edge structure and proposes a new edge stabilization mechanism, providing an important theoretical basis for future graphene material design and applications.