Rapid Decision-Making Tool for Electric Powertrain Sizing for Motorcycles during New Product Development

Mehmet Cagin Kirca,Andrew McGordon,Truong Quang Dinh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/en17020330

IF: 3.2

2024-01-10

Energies

Abstract:As part of the intergovernmental and public interventions to reduce carbon dioxide emissions, there are no existing regulations to ban the sale of petrol motorcycles (PM), but it is expected that motorcycle regulations will follow car regulations with several years of delay. There is an emerging trend in motorcycle uptake, which will lead to new development projects with existing brands, and new brands, and will clearly increase the need for development tools that satisfies design challenges specific to electric motorcycles (EM) and electric powertrains. There is significant importance in motorcycle design to quantify the vehicle-level performance indicators and specifications, which are not limited to total vehicle mass, range, acceleration performance, and top speed. Those performance indicators should be quantified for different powertrain configurations and component selections to identify the most suitable configuration for the specific motorcycle development. In this paper, an innovative powertrain sizing approach is proposed to provide solutions for EMs against the design challenges specific to electric motorcycles. The innovative approach is to apply the practice of design space exploration (DSE) in resilient system design (RSD) to EM development. As a proof of concept, a case study of battery sizing is presented, in which a powertrain sizing tool is used to identify battery pack sizing requirements using requirement-based design (RBD), sensitivity analysis and DSE. The case study shows that the RBD approach allows EM product developers to identify a single solution, while DSE clearly demonstrates the trade-off between different configurations, taking multiple design variables into account. The tool prioritises high accessibility and high confidence with limited information at the early phases of electric motorcycle powertrain component sizing and selection.

energy & fuels

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily addresses the specific challenges faced in the New Product Development (NPD) process of Electric Motorcycles (EM) and proposes a rapid decision-making tool to optimize the design of electric powertrains.

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

1. **Design Challenges**: Existing design methods for electric vehicles and electric motorcycles fail to adequately address challenges specific to motorcycles, such as mass and volume constraints, the trade-off between energy density and power density of lithium-ion batteries, and the impact of motor torque and power specifications on acceleration performance.

2. **Quantification of Requirements and Performance Metrics**: For different powertrain configurations and component selections, there is a need to quantify key performance metrics such as total vehicle mass, range, acceleration performance, and top speed.

3. **Early-Stage Design Evaluation**: There is a lack of effective methods to evaluate vehicle-level performance metrics for different configurations during the early stages of determining and selecting electric motorcycle powertrain component sizes.

### Solution

The paper proposes an innovative powertrain sizing design method, which includes:

1. **Application of Design Space Exploration (DSE)**: Applying design space exploration practices, originally used in Resilient System Design (RSD), to the development of electric motorcycles to better evaluate trade-offs among various design options.

2. **Case Study**: Demonstrating the practical application of the tool through a case study on battery sizing. This case uses methods such as Requirement-Based Design (RBD), sensitivity analysis, and design space exploration to determine the size requirements of the battery pack.

3. **High Usability and High Confidence**: The tool aims to improve the usability and confidence in determining and selecting electric motorcycle powertrain component sizes in the early stages, even with limited information.

In summary, the goal of the paper is to provide a comprehensive methodology to help electric motorcycle manufacturers make more informed decisions when facing specific design challenges, ultimately developing products that meet performance requirements and are cost-effective.