I. Classification, Cause and Symptoms of Mental Illness 1890–1900 in Ontario *

B. Willer,G. Miller

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/070674377702200506

1977-08-01

Canadian Psychiatric Association Journal

Abstract:any other endeavour were examples of poor education (3). Nevertheless, it is evident from the writings of the time that psychiatrists believed that some hereditary predisposition was probably involved, even if it could not be determined precisely. (1) Precipitating causes of illness also emphasized immoral behaviour but placed some importance on family relationships, death in the family, financial crisis, or loss of employment. Physical injury or illness was also considered important as a precipitating cause, although even in these instances hereditary predisposition was considered necessary. Examples of illness included syphilis, "la grippe" and apoplexy. Examples of injury included exposure, sunstroke, and being kicked by a horse. To confuse things slightly, what might be a predisposing cause for one person could be a precipitating cause for another. While mental illness was generally assumed to be a singular (brain) disease, it was determined that illness could only be described as levels or intensity of disease. An early form of illness, characterized by depression, was termed "melancholia." "Mania," characterized by violent outbursts, was considered a later form of illness. There was some uncertainty about patients suffering from epilepsy or dementia. However, by the end of the nineteenth century, dementia had come to be associated with senility, and epilepsy was recognized as a distinct syndrome. Brody (2) reviewed a number of articles in the Journal ofNervous andMental Disease which suggested that the majority of patients in mental hospitals were diagnosed "manic," while "melancholia" was only half as frequent.