Using a Mixed-Methods Approach to Examine the Expanding Reach of Body Classification into the Twenty-First Century

Aishwarya Ramachandran,Stephen Chignell,Yoonseok Choi,Patricia Vertinsky

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5406/21558450.51.1.01

2024-01-01

Journal of Sport History

Abstract:Abstract This article uses a mixed-methods approach combining historical inquiry and quantitative science mapping techniques to examine the expanding reach of the somatotype body measurement and classification system, based on posture photography and anthropometric measurements, well into the twenty-first century. It illuminates the persistence of deterministic thinking about the relationships between physique and athletic ability in physical education and sports science, as well as how these views evolve. While William Sheldon, founder of the somatotype system, increasingly shifted his research focus toward criminal anthropology, physical educators throughout the second half of the twentieth century found the somatotype useful for assessing the physique and performance of Olympic athletes, often drawing on a priori racial and ethnic categories. By the early 2000s, somatotype research was becoming increasingly popular internationally, focused mainly on the measurement and assessment of sporting talent through drawing correlations between body type and sports performance and relying on commonsense assumptions about the innateness of athletic ability. Missing, however, was a deeper consideration of the potential mechanisms or pathways driving these relationships.