Cultural Conflicts in an Intercultural Classroom Discourse and Interpretations from a Cultural Perspective
Yuqin Zhao
2007-01-01
Abstract:With more Chinese immigrating into New Zealand, there are more intercultural classrooms in schools and classes of various levels. Chinese teach Mandarin to New Zealanders and Chinese students are learning English from New Zealand teachers. Due to differences in cultures and educational traditions, teachers and students from different countries present different classroom behaviors. This causes some misunderstandings and even conflicts between teachers and students when they meet in the classroom. Based on the experiences of teaching Mandarin to New Zealanders and learning the MA courses from New Zealand teachers, and other teachers' experiences, the author of this paper discusses some differences in classroom behaviors of Chinese teachers and students and New Zealand teachers and students, and analyzes them from cultural perspectives, such as the concepts and views about kinship relationships, functions of education and roles of teachers in the classroom. With large numbers of Chinese immigrating into western countries and westerners working and studying in China, there are more exchanges of teachers and students between China and western or English speaking countries, such as America, Britain, Canada, Australia and New Zealand. Not only English, but also some other languages, such as Chinese, is learned as a second or foreign language. Teachers and students meet in classrooms either with the English teacher teaching English to Chinese students, or a Chinese teacher teaching Mandarin to English speaking students, forming intercultural classrooms with teachers and students from different cultures. Nowadays, intercultural classrooms are common in China and in English speaking countries. The classroom discourse in China is more oriented towards a hierarchical face system and assumes more respect from students toward the teacher. The teacher would value those who are more obedient and quiet in class, listen to him and follow his instruction with no conditions. He prefers standing in the front of the classroom with more dignity and authority, doing a most noble job of transmitting knowledge and truth to his students. In Chinese classrooms, the atmosphere is usually serious. Students should sit in lines and rows The classroom setting represents a field of communication between teachers and students. When teachers and students from different cultures come into the same classroom, they are faced with some, if not all, differences in classroom behaviors, toward which people have different attitudes and feelings. If these attitudes and feelings go toward extremes, misunderstandings and miscommunications will be caused. Also culture shock might occur when one has expectations of one behavior and gets something completely different (Carol, 1986).