Palestinian refugees in the context of the Hamas–Israel war in Gaza: an analysis through the lens of transitional justice

Y. Kapshuk
DOI: https://doi.org/10.20542/2307-1494-2024-1-28-45
2024-01-01
Pathways to Peace and Security
Abstract:The protracted Palestinian–Israeli conflict has perpetuated significant humanitarian crises. This article examines the problem of the Palestinian refugees from 1948 to the Hamas–Israel conflict starting October 7, 2023, through the lens of transitional justice. Transitional justice addresses past human rights violations in a way that promotes reconciliation. It offers a new perspective on the enduring issue of the Palestinian refugees. The 2023–2024 conflict displaced over 1.7 million people in Gaza, highlighting the need for sustainable solutions. The article first describes the war between Israel and Hamas, focusing on the issue of the Palestinian refugees in Gaza. Next, it reviews the historical context of the Palestinian refugees since 1948 and the two narratives surrounding them. It then explains the principles of transitional justice and analyzes transitional justice elements in past negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians. Finally, it assesses how theory and practice of transitional justice can be applied in the current conflict. The article explores how transitional justice principles such as truth commissions and reparations can address historical and ongoing injustices despite mistrust, political resistance, and other challenges. The current environment makes it difficult to implement transitional justice effectively. While applying transitional justice to the Palestinian refugees in Gaza could help acknowledge past abuses, provide reparations, and prevent future violence, significant political challenges must be overcome. Nevertheless, this approach, though fraught with difficulties, offers a potential pathway for lasting peace and reconciliation in the region.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?