The Ship is Laden with Rice and Salt: A Comparison of Two Sailing Models on an Early 17th Century Trade Route Between Java and Sumatra

Wesa Perttola,Emma Slayton,Veronica Walker Vadillo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11457-024-09419-1

2024-10-06

Journal of Maritime Archaeology

Abstract:Archaeological and historical sailing modeling has become an increasingly productive field of study in the twenty-first century. The research has largely concentrated on methodological development, yet comparisons between models have so far been lacking. In this paper we juxtapose two directed sailing models, Digital Navigator and qtVlm, on a route from East Java to South Sumatra. In the early seventeenth century, the former was a major producer and exporter of rice and salt, while especially Jambi, Indonesia, on the island of Sumatra, had become dependent on imports due to cash-cropping of black pepper. Our simulation results show the optimal sailing season on this route falls between May and September, and that La Niña events somewhat affect the length of this time window. During favorable winds both models produce quite similar routes. In adverse winds there is more variation between the models and the temporal frequency of wind data has more marked effects on routing. The models' sailing durations match fairly well to the one measured from the Selden Map of China, but the simulated optimized routes tend to take more direct open sea routes than the coast-hugging route on the map. This implies that other factors such as ease of navigation played a more significant role in route selection than mere efficiency. Furthermore, a comparison to the production schedules of rice and salt in the Gresik region shows that products from the same summer's harvests would have been available for export to Sumatra.