Abstract:Shapley values originated in cooperative game theory but are extensively used today as a model-agnostic explanation framework to explain predictions made by complex machine learning models in the industry and academia. There are several algorithmic approaches for computing different versions of Shapley value explanations. Here, we consider Shapley values incorporating feature dependencies, referred to as conditional Shapley values, for predictive models fitted to tabular data. Estimating precise conditional Shapley values is difficult as they require the estimation of non-trivial conditional expectations. In this article, we develop new methods, extend earlier proposed approaches, and systematize the new refined and existing methods into different method classes for comparison and evaluation. The method classes use either Monte Carlo integration or regression to model the conditional expectations. We conduct extensive simulation studies to evaluate how precisely the different method classes estimate the conditional expectations, and thereby the conditional Shapley values, for different setups. We also apply the methods to several real-world data experiments and provide recommendations for when to use the different method classes and approaches. Roughly speaking, we recommend using parametric methods when we can specify the data distribution almost correctly, as they generally produce the most accurate Shapley value explanations. When the distribution is unknown, both generative methods and regression models with a similar form as the underlying predictive model are good and stable options. Regression-based methods are often slow to train but quickly produce the Shapley value explanations once trained. The vice versa is true for Monte Carlo-based methods, making the different methods appropriate in different practical situations.

Explaining black box decisions by Shapley cohort refinement

Variable importance without impossible data

Absolute Shapley Value

Shapley variable importance cloud for interpretable machine learning

Model free variable importance for high dimensional data

Shapley Marginal Surplus for Strong Models

Explainable AI: Efficiency Sequential Shapley Updating Approach

Shapley variable importance clouds for interpretable machine learning

Shapley Value: from Cooperative Game to Explainable Artificial Intelligence

A comparative study of methods for estimating model-agnostic Shapley value explanations

A Comparative Study of Methods for Estimating Conditional Shapley Values and When to Use Them

Explaining Predictive Uncertainty with Information Theoretic Shapley Values

Shapley variable importance cloud for machine learning models

Approximating the Shapley Value without Marginal Contributions

Shapley Curves: A Smoothing Perspective

Variable importance analysis with interpretable machine learning for fair risk prediction

Improving the Sampling Strategy in KernelSHAP

Quantifying the Reliance of Black-Box Decision-Makers on Variables of Interest

Comparing interpretability and explainability for feature selection

An exact game-theoretic variable importance index for generalized additive models

Derivative-based Shapley value for global sensitivity analysis and machine learning explainability