Abstract:Resistance to the use of prescribed fire is strong among many private land managers despite the advantages it offers for maintaining fire-adapted ecosystems. Even managers who are aware of the benefits of using prescribed fire as a management tool avoid using it, citing potential liability as a major reason for their aversion. Recognizing the importance of prescribed fire for ecosystem management and the constraints current statutory schemes impose on its use, several states in the United States have undertaken prescribed burn statutory reform. The stated purpose of these statutory reforms, often called "right to burn" or "prescribed burning" acts, is to encourage prescribed burning for resource protection, public safety, and land management. Our research assessed the consequences of prescribed burn statutory reform by identifying legal incentives and impediments to prescribed fire application for ecosystem restoration and management, as well as fuel reduction. Specifically, we explored the relationship between prescribed burning laws and decisions made by land managers by exploiting a geographic-based natural experiment to compare landowner-prescribed fire use in contiguous counties with different regulations and legal liability standards. Controlling for potentially confounding variables, we found that private landowners in counties with gross negligence liability standards burn significantly more hectares than those in counties with simple negligence standards (F6,72 = 4.16, P = 0.046). There was no difference in hectares burned on private land between counties with additional statutorily mandated regulatory requirements and those requiring only a permit to complete a prescribed burn (F6,72 = 1.42, P = 0.24) or between counties with burn ban exemptions for certified prescribed burn managers and those with no exemptions during burn bans (F6,72 = 1.39, P = 0.24). Lawmakers attempting to develop prescribed burning statutes to promote the safe use of prescribed fire should consider the benefits of lower legal liability standards in conjunction with regulatory requirements that promote safety for those managing forests and rangelands with fire. Moreover, ecologists and land managers might be better prepared and motivated to educate stakeholder groups who influence prescribed fire policies if they are cognizant of the manner in which policy regulations and liability concerns create legal barriers that inhibit the implementation of effective ecosystem management strategies.

"Pleasure to Burn": A Comprehensive Look into the History of Censoring Literature in School Environments

Policy Dialogue on Twenty-First-Century Book Banning in the US

“It’s Bigger Than Just a Book Challenge”: A Collective Case Study of Educators’ Experiences With Censorship

The Hydra Nature of Book Banning and Censorship

Jazz, Drama, and a Librarian: Advocating Against Book Censorship in Public Schools

Literature in the Standards Paradigm: An Evolution of Gains and Losses

Developing an empathic analysis: Using critical literacy, dialogue, and inquiry with literature to explore the issues with gender labels

Book bans in political context: Evidence from US schools

Professional Book Reviews: The Rights of Readers in Our Schools

Development of beliefs about censorship

The Historical Significance of Titicut Follies in Psychiatric Treatment: An Anti-Censorship Perspective

A Case Study of East Asian Invention Censorship in the U.S. Education–Printing Press and Compass

Spare the rod and spoil the pervert: Corporal punishment and the nineteenth century in popular culture

Writers vs censorship: Slovenian experience in the context of the 19th century

Understanding the Attacks on Social–Emotional Learning: Strategizing on the Response and Advocacy of School Mental Health Practitioners

A study on corruption in educational administration: focusing on elementary, middle and high schools

Public Librarians in the Hot Seat? Moral Injury in the Post-Truth Era

Legal barriers to effective ecosystem management: exploring linkages between liability, regulations, and prescribed fire.

Opening Doors: Teaching LGBTQ-themed Young Adult Literature for an Inclusive Curriculum

What’s With All This Race Talk Anyway? A Literature Review on Antiracist Education

Prosocial motives underlie scientific censorship by scientists: A perspective and research agenda