Abstract:Previous papers at TPRC and elsewhere have contributed to our understanding of the significance of automated, data-driven decision systems, especially when used for regulation. The objective of this research is to analyse two specific and interrelated developments in order to ascertain the extent to which they call for the development of new types of model and new approaches to algorithmic regulation. The first of these is ‘fintech’ - in particular the consolidation and transfer of investment decisions from human to algorithmic control and the migration of financial intermediation, payment services and data curation beyond traditionally regulated financial entities. The second is regtech – automated and real-time provision of compliance-related information to regulators. Both pose challenges: practical, legal and ethical difficulties in auditing and assurance; moving beyond individual reporting entities to systems as units of analysis and control; maintaining the efficiency and efficacy of contracts, markets and regulatory obligations; and ensuring that the resulting system is as low-cost and flexible as possible (but not more so). These difficulties are not just pragmatic; recent work on data ethics highlights the difficulty of detecting and correcting incorrect decisions (let alone dealing with their indirect and systemic impacts) and the inevitable fragmentation of responsibility among those officially responsible, technology players, programmers, data sources, etc. The research draws on a set of cases to include (at least) digital wealth managers and automated spectrum use reporting and trading. The ‘red thread’ is the extent to which algorithms can usefully be considered as more than just faster and more consistent was of implementing decision rules. Four alternatives are considered: i) the impact of interactions among algorithms and the persistence and manipulability of the ‘histories’ on which they operate (in other words, the difference between source code and running instances); ii) application of principal-agent analysis to entities that are imperfectly auditable, act on the basis of imperfectly observable information and/or can only be controlled be rules that operate at the ‘speed of information’ (slower or faster than the algorithm itself); iii) modelling algorithms as links in a network (connecting people, data, and institutions) using the tools of network game theory; and iv) an evolutionary approach which views algorithm types as ‘species’ whose populations interact in a market ecosystem. The first three alternatives apply existing theoretical methods to stylised versions of the cases; the fourth uses simulations based on exemplary decision rules (moving averages, CAPM/OPM, Kalman filters and Bollinger band strategies) and different regulatory options. An interesting outcome is the possibility that continuous reporting can enable new types of dynamic regulation that are less burdensome and more effective than today’s static alternatives.

Reducing the regulatory burden: How can technology revolutionise compliance processes and make complying with multiple regulations more efficient?

RegTech innovations streamlining compliance, reducing costs in the financial sector

How compliance leaders are driving efficiency and creating more effective compliance processes

RegTech Solutions: Enhancing compliance and risk management in the financial industry

FCToken: A Flexible Framework for Blockchain-Based Compliance Tokenization

RegTech: Technology-driven compliance and its effects on profitability, operations, and market structure

Environmental Compliance Through Regulation Technology

Regulatory technologies in traditional industries as an element of the digital transformation: Perspectives for development

RTS - an Integrated Analytic Solution for Managing Regulation Changes and Their Impact on Business Compliance.

The Transformative Impact of Financial Technology (FinTech) on Regulatory Compliance in the Banking Sector

FinTech, RegTech and the Reconceptualization of Financial Regulation

Get with the Program: Fintech Meets Regtech in the Light-Touch Sandbox

Design Challenges for GDPR RegTech

Automating Sanctions Compliance: Aligning Regulatory Technology, Rules and Goals

A Digital Twin Approach for Adaptive Compliance in Cyber-Physical Systems: Case of Smart Warehouse Logistics

Automated Compliance Blueprint Optimization with Artificial Intelligence

Potential applications of emerging technologies to anti-money laundering compliance programmes

LEGAL IMPLICATIONS OF BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY FOR TAX COMPLIANCE AND FINANCIAL REGULATION

Automated Cybersecurity Compliance and Threat Response Using AI, Blockchain & Smart Contracts

Navigating the Fin-Tech Revolution: Legal Challenges and Opportunities in the Digital Transformation of Finance

Three Decades of Formal Methods in Business Process Compliance: A Systematic Literature Review