Stockpile Volume Estimation in Open and Confined Environments: A Review
Ahmad Alsayed,Mostafa R. A. Nabawy
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/drones7080537
IF: 5.532
2023-08-20
Drones
Abstract:This paper offers a comprehensive review of traditional and advanced stockpile volume-estimation techniques employed within both outdoor and indoor confined spaces, whether that be a terrestrial- or an aerial-based technique. Traditional methods, such as manual measurement and satellite imagery, exhibit limitations in handling irregular or constantly changing stockpiles. On the other hand, more advanced techniques, such as global navigation satellite system (GNSS), terrestrial laser scanning (TLS), drone photogrammetry, and airborne light detection and ranging (LiDAR), have emerged to address these challenges, providing enhanced accuracy and efficiency. Terrestrial techniques relying on GNSS, TLS, and LiDAR offer accurate solutions; however, to minimize or eliminate occlusions, surveyors must access geometrically constrained places, representing a serious safety hazard. With the speedy rise of drone technologies, it was not unexpected that they found their way to the stockpile volume-estimation application, offering advantages such as ease of use, speed, safety, occlusion elimination, and acceptable accuracy compared to current standard methods, such as TLS and GNSS. For outdoor drone missions, image-based approaches, like drone photogrammetry, surpass airborne LiDAR in cost-effectiveness, ease of deployment, and color information, whereas airborne LiDAR becomes advantageous when mapping complex terrain with vegetation cover, mapping during low-light or dusty conditions, and/or detecting small or narrow objects. Indoor missions, on the other hand, face challenges such as low lighting, obstacles, dust, and limited space. For such applications, most studies applied LiDAR sensors mounted on tripods or integrated on rail platforms, whereas very few utilized drone solutions. In fact, the choice of the most suitable technique/approach depends on factors such as site complexity, required accuracy, project cost, and safety considerations. However, this review puts more focus on the potential of drones for stockpile volume estimation in confined spaces, and explores emerging technologies, such as solid-state LiDAR and indoor localization systems, which hold significant promise for the future. Notably, further research and real-world applications of these technologies will be essential for realizing their full potential and overcoming the challenges of operating robots in confined spaces.
English Else