Music Criticism in China Requires Critical Introspection of Cultures
Minkang Yang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0447-6573.2010.02.022
2010-01-01
Abstract:Since the beginning of opening up and reforms in the 1980's,music criticism in the fields of traditional Chinese music,modern and contemporary music history and Western music history has experienced frequent controversies over many issues of cultural relations among such different regions as China-Western musical culture relations and such different social classes as the elite culture and the grassroots culture.Ethnomusicologists and cultural anthropologists have been paying much attention to such issues,and there are also growing voices in favour of introducing such methodology into all traditional musicological disciplines.However,more focus used to be placed upon how to adopt the anthropological way of observing objects of research from the cultural perspectives.What should actually be the focal point for our learning when such a broad topic is under discussion? In other words, why should we learn from the anthropological methods? There are various opinions on this,but my conclusion,nevertheless,is that music criticism in China should pay attention to and learn from the critical introspection of cultures initiated by anthropologists as well as philosophers and sociologists of the present time. 1.What is critical introspection of cultures? In the author's view, this refers to the norms and standards of self-containing,self-questioning and critical introspection over the cultural outlook,academic behaviour and research achievement of researchers in accordance with the criteria of the diversified culture theory.This was initiated by schol- ars of philosophy,sociology and,in particular,anthropology in Europe and America.Since this is group self-disciplinary behaviour performed by scholars who,as strong social classes and mainstream groups,own favourable right to speak,there has been an academic trend of attempting to transcend different academic schools and socio-cultural communities by not only opposing to cultural hegemonism,but also disagreeing to extreme nationalism.The author believes that under the current situation of imbalance among different social classes, communities and groups concerning their various cultural rights including the right to speak,and seeing the fact that it is hard to eliminate such phenomenon in a short while,it is rather beneficial to both the criticizer and the criticized to promote this kind of critical introspection of cultures among the critics. For the criticizer,this is nothing but a sword of Damocles which requires not only acute insight in terms of culture and academic learning,but certain bravery and courage. 2.The diversity of objects for music criticism and the imbalance of their cultural rights The fact that there is actual imbalance of all cultural rights including the right to speak as a result of differentiation of musical culture in terms of regions,classes and communities is a dilemma for music criticism itself in China.This,therefore, calls for more reasonable and fair criteria for music criticism. In conclusion,it is a necessary attitude for music critics to conduct their research work self-consciously or subconsciously in the manner of dual perspectives of"subject-object"and"insider -outsider"and in the concept of"transpositional thinking"when facing an alien culture as object of cultural research.If we as a member of"main culture"(the Han culture,or a certain community of greater size,or a mainstream social class) possess too strong sense of being the"master"or"big brother"and are even accustomed to taking over what should be done by others when facing the music cultures of"alien-culture"societies or classes,we would then easily commit faults, which have been proved by countless historical lessons. Today,there are various kinds of music competitions and awards(including application for World Cultural Heritage) that cover different communities and social classes.While the basic right to speak is in the hand of relevant government bodies and the very few experts,how could cultural criticism be made between themselves and the entire academic circle,and among various social classes or communities? Therefore,it becomes a common topic for both the government bodies,academics and music critics to discuss how to make the best use of the right committed by the people and how to prevent from making the same mistakes as in the past.To achieve the objective, the indispensable approach should be to learn as much as possible from the critical introspection of anthropologists and bring into full play the"self-discipline"and"self-questioning"functions of music criticism in China.