Abstract:Purpose In Portugal, between 1989 and 2010, capital gains from corporate shares were exempted, while gains from other instruments, like limited liability companies (LLC) equity stakes, were taxed. Inevitably, this non-neutral tax treatment originated a notorious tax arbitrage, consisting in the transformation of the legal status of a LLC into a corporation, the subsequent share sale and tax exemption. In tax litigation, many arbitration rulings were delivered, with widely divergent decisions. The purpose of this paper, using a blend of the legal research method and case analysis, is to discuss three research questions. Should the general anti-abuse clause (GAAC) be applied to this tax planning operation? Why the divergence in arbitration rulings? Is this anomalous arbitration outcome because of the wording the GAAC and its complexity or, contrarily, does it emerge from the disconnection between the set of rules governing capital gains taxation and the legislative intent that is behind such rules? Design/methodology/approach The methodology used in this paper is based on a mix of the legal research method and case analysis. In the case of legal research, a hermeneutic approach – meaning that documents, texts and their interpretation can produce important fruits to the development of the field – is a tested and fruitful approach. Besides being a hermeneutic discipline, it is an argumentative one. By exposing arguments that confirm or deny particular solutions, legal research (e.g. in criminal, business or administrative law) can influence better legislative choices by political actors. Advantages of case analysis include lessons learned from observation. The author discusses if the application of the GAAC to an arrangement that originated a tax exemption can be validated by the usual interpretative lines that doctrine sustains should be observed when a GAAC is used to void legal schemes. The pros and cons of tax arbitration are also highlighted. Findings The conclusion of this paper is that the GAAC is not the crux of the problem. Instead, a contradictory or, at least, disconnected relation between the expressed intent of legislators and the wording of capital gains tax clauses is, in our view, the main reason for such divergent arbitration rulings on the same issue. Practical implications The author believes that the paper is a contribution to the literature, given the global use of anti-abuse clauses and the interpretative complexities they originate. Moreover, the analysis in this paper is carried out in a legal setting where a disconnection is detectable between the expressed legislative intent and the legal drafting of personal income tax rules related to the exemption of capital gains. Studying the complexity added by this feature of the Portuguese legislation serves as a reminder of the importance of careful and well-crafted wording to achieve consistent court outcomes. Originality/value The paper has value to governments, tax authorities and tax managers, given the ever-increasing use of anti-abuse clauses in many countries, and the potential use of arbitration in similar settings.

A lei anticorrupção e o acordo de leniência

THE IMPLEMENTATION OF INTERNATIONAL ANTI-CORRUPTION LAW IN BUSINESS: LEGAL CONTROL OF CORRUPTION DIRECTED TO TRANSNATIONAL CORPORATIONS

Weakening constitutional rules through anti-corruption and impunity discourses: Analyzing the impact of the “Operação Lava-jato” (Car Wash Operation) on the presumption of innocence in Brazil

Combating Corporate Fraud in Brazil and the Potential Impact of Bill No. 2581/2023

Corporate Behavior: An Exploratory Study of the Brazilian Tax Management from a Corporate Social Responsibility Perspective

JUDICIAL CONTROL IN THE NON-PROSECUTION AGREEMENT

Jobs and Punishment: Public Opinion on Leniency for White-Collar Crime

Fighting corruption: A theoretical articulation of the themes of social responsibility, corporate governance, and agency theory

Compliance and Anti-Corruption Mechanisms in Industries in the South Region of Brazil

Tax avoidance, anti-abuse clauses and arbitration courts: a note on capital gains’ exemption

Another Brick in the Building of the EU Rule of Law: Anti-Corruption

O NE BIS IN IDEM E O PRINCÍPIO DO DESCONTO NA LEI DE INTRODUÇÃO ÀS NORMAS DO DIREITO BRASILEIRO

Effectiveness of Anti-Corruption Laws in Developing Countries

Governança nas contratações públicas sob a perspectiva da nova lei de licitações e contratos administrativos / Governance in public contracting under the perspective of the new bidding law and administrative contracts

Thirty Years of Studies on Transparency, Accountability, and Corruption in the Public Sector: The State of the Art and Opportunities for Future Research

Criminal investigation, judicial police and Public Office

Antimonopoly compliance as a circumstance which mitigates administrative responsibility

Regulation of private sector bribery as a crime of corruption

On Anti-corruption by the Rule of Law

A model-based assessment of the cost-benefit balance and the plea bargain in criminality -- A qualitative case study of the Covid-19 epidemic shedding light on the "car wash operation" in Brazil

Practice of the member states of the European Union in the field of anti-corruption regulation