Abstract:Background As textbooks constitute a foundational component of medical education, it is imperative to conduct a rigorous evaluation of their efficacy by examining the fundamental elements and tools utilized within these textbooks and how multiple factors may alter the effectiveness of such components. Materials and methods We conducted a cross-sectional, survey-based study where 251 subjects anonymously rated the effectiveness of different tools and elements/factors used in medical textbooks using 5-point Likert scales. The population surveyed included year 1 to 5 medical students at Alfaisal University, where students are admitted to medical school directly after high school, with an approximately equal male-to-female admission rate. Students were asked to rate the effectiveness of the following tools: chapter summary, end-of-chapter questions, tables of contents, graphic elements, diagrams, tables, flowcharts, mind maps, sidebars, and links to online resources. In admission, they were asked to rate textbooks regarding the following elements/factors: text clarity, directness to the concept intended, flow of ideas, language complexity, and clinical (vertical) and multidisciplinary (horizontal) integration. The Chi-square, post-hoc, Spearman's correlation, and Kruskall-Wallis tests were used in the statistical analysis to determine the differences and correlations in the students' self-ratings of different variables. Results The students rated tools such as diagrams and graphic elements as the most effective. Graphic elements were rated as significantly more effective by first- and fourth-year students. This corresponds to being exposed to new environments (the first exposure to the study of medicine and the first exposure to clinical clerkship), indicating their effectiveness in introducing new concepts and setting of change. Furthermore, end-of-chapter summaries and questions were rated significantly as being more effective by females (P<0.05). The aim behind using textbooks and the frequency might be governed by how students rate textbooks regarding multiple elements or factors, including directness to the concept intended, flow of ideas, and language complexity. Interestingly, all the above findings were consistent throughout all grade point average groups. Discussion In the rising age of e-learning, our study shows that the tools employed by textbooks remain effective. Our findings are partially consistent with existing literature, which underscores correlations between demographic variables and learning styles. We show that the effectiveness of various tools employed in textbooks can vary depending on the educational setting. While demographic factors generally did not impact students' perceptions of tool effectiveness, gender-specific differences were observed in the perceived effectiveness of end-of-chapter summaries and questions, with female students rating them as more effective, which aligns with existing literature. Conclusions Our study shows that students still perceive the tools employed by textbooks as effective. The perceived effectiveness of various tools utilized within textbooks may be influenced by certain demographic factors and settings, with graphics often proving the most efficacious. This study provides valuable insights for authors of medical textbooks, helping them optimize the usage of various tools by considering the specific characteristics and requirements of the intended audience.

Evaluation of New Tools for Embryology Teaching Experience of Tangier Medical School in Morocco

Effectiveness of Multimedia Approaches in Embryology Teaching: A Scoping Review

Implementation of Online Teaching in Medical Education: Lessons Learned from Students’ Perspectives during the Health Crisis in Marrakesh, Morocco

Human Embryology teaching mediated through a virtual environment room

Pedagogical Evaluation of Digital Technology to Enhance Dental Student Learning

Animate! Breathing new life into an old pedagogy: Human embryology teaching reenvisioned

The use of active methodologies for the teaching of human embryology: A systematic review

The role of Moodle-based surgical skills illustrations using 3D animation in undergraduate training

Effectiveness of virtual teaching of diagnostic and interventional imaging fundamentals to Egyptian medical students: an analytical cross-sectional study

Effect of peer learning strategy on Technical Nursing Students’ Knowledge, Skills and Attitudes.

Training Based on Simulation Pedagogy: Evaluation of Participants’ Satisfaction with the First National Forum on Simulation in Nursing in Morocco

ENHANCING ONLINE PRACTICAL COURSES IN MECHANICAL ENGINEERING: DEVELOPMENT AND ANALYSIS OF INNOVATIVE METHODS

Enhancing medicinal chemistry knowledge and student interest: Incorporating pharmacy practice related case studies and active-learning strategies

The impact of flipped classroom: Evaluation of cognitive level and attitude of undergraduate medical students

Evaluation of a CIAP session for students in Medicine, Pediatrics module

Examining the Effectiveness of Educational Tools and Elements Used in Medical Textbooks: Students' Perspective

Three-dimensional Virtual Reality as an Innovative Teaching and Learning Tool for Human Anatomy Courses in Medical Education: A Mixed Methods Study

A four-Axis-Method to Evaluate a Part of an Undergraduate Medical Students' Curriculum

Promoting design thinking in nursing education: Experience of Moroccan undergraduate students in a surgical department

Study on the Combination of “Online Open Course” and “Cloud Class” in the Embryology Teaching: a randomized controlled trial

Blended learning model via small private online course improves active learning and academic performance of embryology