Abstract:With the increasing concentration of shares in the hands of large institutional investors, combined with greater involvement in corporate governance, the antitrust risk of common ownership has moved to center stage. Through an excess of enthusiasm, portfolio managers could end up exposing their firms and the portfolio companies to huge antitrust liability. In this Article, we start from basic antitrust principles to sketch out an antitrust compliance program for institutional investors and for the investor relations groups in portfolio companies. In doing so, we address the fundamental antitrust issues (explicit and tacit coordination) raised by the presence of common ownership by large, diversified investors. We then turn to more speculative concerns that have garnered a great deal of attention and that, to our eyes, threaten to divert attention from the core antitrust issues. We critically examine the claims of this newer literature, as illustrated by Azar, Schmaltz and Tecu (2017), that existing ownership patterns in the airline industry results in substantially higher prices. We then turn to the argument in Elhauge (2016) that existing ownership patterns violate Section 7 of the Clayton Act. Finally, we find the policy recommendations of Posner, Scott Morton, and Weyl (2017) to limit the ownership shares of multiple firms in oligopolistic industries to be overly stringent. To limit the chilling effect of antitrust on the valuable role of institutional investors in corporate governance, we propose a quasi “safe harbor” that protects investors from antitrust liability when their ownership share is less than 15 percent, the investors have no board representation, and they only engage in “normal” corporate governance activities.

A Critical Review of the Common Ownership Literature

Common Ownership, Institutional Investors, and Antitrust

Does Control-Ownership Divergence Impair Market Liquidity in an Emerging Market? Evidence from China

Theory and Measurement of Common Ownership

Critical dimensions in the empirical measurement of common shareholding

Common Ownership and Competition in Mergers and Acquisitions

Common Ownership, Executive Compensation, and Product Market Competition

Does common ownership constrain managerial rent extraction? Evidence from insider trading profitability

The New Invisible Hand: How Common Owners Use the Media as a Strategic Tool

Common Institutional Ownership and Earnings Management*

Does common institutional ownership restrain corporate financialization?

Common‐Ownership Versus Cross‐Ownership: Evidence from the Automobile Industry

Frenemies: Corporate Advertising under Common Ownership

Does Equity Ownership Matter for Corporate Social Responsibility? A Literature Review of Theories and Recent Empirical Findings

Common Ownership, Price Informativeness, and Corporate Investment

Common Institutional Ownership and Stock Price Crash Risk

Common Ownership and Goodwill Impairments

Too Much Of A Good Thing: How Does Ownership Concentration Affect Innovation Speed In Chinese Manufacturing Firms?

Antitrust for Institutional Investors

Ownership Structure and Firm Performance: A Comprehensive Review and Empirical Analysis

Directors' Ownership in the U.S. Mutual Fund Industry