Development of an Instrument to Measure Teaching Style in Japan: The Teaching Style Assessment Scale.
Fumiko Yoshida,Takaaki Iwasaki,G. Conti,Toyoaki Yamauchi
Abstract:AbstractTeaching style has been a popular concept for many years. Teaching style refers to the distinct qualities displayed by a teacher that are persistent from situation to situation regardless of the content. The Principles of Adult Learning Scale (PALS) has been used extensively in the West for measuring teaching style in relationship to the adult education literature, but no version has been available for use in Japan. Therefore, this research used PALS as the foundation for creating a new instrument to measure teaching style in Japan. Following a rigorous translation process, data were collected from a national sample of 1,111 nursing educators. Factor analysis and correlation were used to establish the construct and content validity of the new instrument. Reliability was established with Cronbach's alpha. The new 30-item instrument was named the Teaching Style Assessment Scale and is available in both Japanese and English for use either for personal self-assessment or for research purposes.BackgroundA crucial issue of Japanese nursing education is practicing Evidence-Based Nursing (Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare, 2008). The amount of research on Evidence-Based Nursing has been increasing since the need for Evidence-Based Nursing was reported (Asakawa, 2011). The nurse practicing Evidence-Based Nursing acquires learning skills such as critical thinking and self-directed learning. These skills are essential for nursing competencies and require a learning environment in which teachers encourage learners to apply the higher-order cognitive skills in Bloom's taxonomy of cognitive behaviors (Heimlich & Norland, 1994).Critical thinking is essential for Evidence-Based Nursing practice, and developing these skills requires a student-centered approach (Chipas, 1995; Schaeffer & Zygmount, 2003). The National Leagues for Nursing in the USA proposed the necessity for student-centered approaches to learning. This position is congruent with the long history of adult learning theory in the United States in which the learner-centered concepts of andragogy and self-directed learning form the twin pillars (Merriam, 2001).In his original description of andragogy, Knowles (1970) pointed out that "the behavior of the teacher probably influences the character of the learning climate more than any other single factor" (p. 41). Moreover, research has shown that "teaching does make a difference....Teaching is the human connection between the content and the environment and the learners" (Heimlich & Norland, 1994, p. 109). There are two basic approaches for the teacher making this human connection with the learners. These are the teacher-centered approach and the learner-centered approach (Conti, 2004). With the teacher-centered approach, "the teacher's role is to design an environment which stimulates the desired behavior and discourages those that have been determined to be undesirable" (p. 77). While the teacher-centered approach focuses upon the actions of the teacher in planning and controlling the learning environment, the learner-centered approach is concerned with the personal development of each individual learner, and the focus therefore is upon the individual learner. "Although a teacher-centered approach is widely practiced in adult education, the learner-centered approach is strongly supported in the field's literature" (p. 78)."Teaching style refers to the distinct qualities displayed by a teacher that are persistent from situation to situation regardless of the content" (Conti, 2004, pp. 76-77). Teaching style is much broader than the specific teaching strategies and methods that are employed to accomplish a specific instructional objective (Conti, 1989, 2004). Teachers enter the teaching-learning transaction with a definite set of values (Brookfield, 1986), and these in turn influence the teacher's beliefs about the nature of the learner, the purpose of the curriculum, and the role of the teacher in the classroom (Darkenwald & Merriam, 1982). …
Psychology,Education