Effectiveness of real-world marketing of organic foods and beverages: A systematic review of recent evidence

Alexandra Sadler,Dominic Moran,Lindsay Jaacks

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pstr.0000123

2024-08-21

PLOS Sustainability and Transformation

Abstract:Increasing consumer demand for organic foods and beverages is critical to boost sustainable agricultural production. Marketing interventions can be an effective way of influencing consumer preferences, but little is known about the effectiveness of these interventions at increasing demand for organic foods and beverages. This review synthesises recent evidence from studies evaluating real-world marketing interventions that aim to increase consumer demand for organic foods and beverages. Five databases were systematically searched and 18,743 titles and abstracts were screened against eligibility criteria. 21 studies covering 29 marketing interventions were included and assessed for risk of bias using the Evidence Project risk of bias tool. We found that price premiums had negative or no effects on overall consumer demand, although a subset of customers were willing to pay higher prices. Price promotions had mixed effects depending on product and customer type. Some place-based interventions–such as arranging organic products in a cluster and ensuring ready availability of these products–had positive and statistically significant impacts on consumer demand. Some promotional interventions–such as including organic messaging near product displays and securing newspaper coverage–were generally effective at increasing consumer demand. Ultimately, the effectiveness of these interventions differed across product categories, message framing, and the type of store and customer, necessitating strategic targeting of organic marketing interventions to promote more sustainable consumption. Organic agriculture has many benefits over conventional agriculture, from protecting biodiversity to promoting public health by reducing exposure to harmful chemicals. As a result, many countries are now setting targets for organic production. However, consumer demand for organic products lags behind. Increasing consumer demand for organic foods and beverages is critical in order to boost organic production. Marketing interventions can be an effective way of influencing consumer preferences, but little is known about how effective these types of interventions are at increasing demand for organic foods and beverages. We summarised recent evidence on the effectiveness of marketing interventions at increasing demand for organic foods and beverages. We found that price premiums had negative or no effects on consumer demand, although a subset of consumers were willing to pay higher prices. Price promotions had mixed effects depending on product and customer type. Some place-based interventions–such as placing organic products together in one part of the store–had positive impacts on consumer demand. Some promotional interventions–such as including organic messaging near product displays and newspaper coverage–were effective at increasing consumer demand. Effectiveness differed across the type of product, store and customer, suggesting that organic marketing interventions need to be targeted strategically in order to promote more sustainable consumption.