Abstract:Advanced urban-planning processes need methods and analysis tools to guide cities toward sustainable urban planning. This provides a realistic and specific urban strategy for each city. Leveraging current developments in various European Smart City projects (MAtchUP and MAKING-CITY), a city-level evaluation framework is proposed to support cities in their strategic-planning process. This process goes through the definition of a methodology to help municipalities in the progress of cities toward sustainability and smartness. Then, through the city-level evaluation, city needs and challenges are identified in order to help municipalities when prioritizing a city strategy. It also aims to evaluate the current status of the city to know to what extent the city is sustainable and smart, as well as to monitor the progress of the city to become sustainable and smart. This evaluation also provides information to the municipality and sets the methodology included in this paper to benchmark and compare multiple aspects within and between cities. This indicator-based methodology enables assessing specific characteristics of the city, diagnosing challenges or discovering patterns through reliable metrics, but also allows comparing various aspects of cities thanks to the normalization and weighting of indicators and the calculation of indexes. Based on the outcome of the literature review, the structure of the city-evaluation framework is performed under the concept of sustainable development, establishing a framework for comparison and evaluation. This framework works as a baseline for all cities in the context of defining their targets, needs, priority areas or action lines. The definition of this methodology has been a learning process based on the study of several methods of normalization, weighting and aggregation, such as the ones described by the Joint Research Centre (JRC) from the European Commission through the Competence Centre on Composite Indicators and Scoreboards (COIN), to build the indexes by category and application field. The sensitivity analysis stage would be the last step to examine the suitability of the proposed evaluation methodology, from the selection of indicators to aggregation techniques. As a result, city’s needs, priorities and progress will be easily identified thanks to the both numerical and graphical results, from which to establish strategic objectives and priority actions in the planning processes for urban transformation.

Urban typologies and urban sustainability: A comparative and landscape-based study in the city of Valencia

Temporal Sustainability Efficiency Analysis of Urban Areas Via Data Envelopment Analysis and the Hypervolume Indicator: Application to London Boroughs

Assessing the sustainability of contrasting land use scenarios through the Socioecological Integrated Analysis (SIA) of the metropolitan green infrastructure in Barcelona

Integrating landscape ecology in urban green infrastructure planning: A multi-scale approach for sustainable development

Morphometric Indicators for the Definition of New Territorial Units in the Periurban Space: Application to the Metropolitan Area of Valencia (Spain)

Beyond urban–rural dichotomy: Exploring socioeconomic and land-use processes of change in Spain (1991–2011)

Urban Sustainability Transitions in Two Frontrunner Cities: Insights from the Multi-level Perspective

Integrating social preferences analysis for multifunctional peri-urban farming in planning. An application by multi-criteria analysis techniques and stakeholders

Sustainability and Water Sensitive Cities: Analysis for Intermediary Cities in Andalusia

Sustainable urban dynamics in coastal cities: A comparative study through digital footprints

Sustainable Resilience in Urban Land Use

Are vital neighbourhoods socially privileged? Exploring the spatial relationship between urban vitality and urban vulnerability

Urban Cohabscapes: exploring European Co-Habitative landScapes diversity, in the ECOLOPES framework.

Land Use, Travel Patterns and Gender in Barcelona: A Sequence Analysis Approach

City-Level Evaluation: Categories, Application Fields and Indicators for Advanced Planning Processes for Urban Transformation

Spatial Analysis Model for the Evaluation of the Territorial Adequacy of the Urban Process in Coastal Areas

Comparing and modeling land use organization in cities

Urban Scene Protection and Unconventional Practices—Contemporary Landscapes in World Heritage Cities of Spain

Characterising the rural-urban gradient through the participatory mapping of ecosystem services: insights for landscape planning

Mapping Adolescents' Sense of Place and Perceptions of Change in an Urban-Rural Transition Area

Modelling urban form: A multidimensional typology of urban occupation for spatial analysis