Abstract:Following the pioneering efforts of a federal Head Start program, U.S. state policymakers have rapidly expanded access to Early Care and Education (ECE) programs with strong bipartisan support. Within the past decade the enrollment of 4 year-olds has roughly doubled in state-funded preschool. Despite these public investments, the content and priorities of early childhood legislation–enacted and failed–have rarely been examined. This study integrates perspectives from public policy, political science, developmental science, and machine learning in examining state ECE bills in identifying key factors associated with legislative success. Drawing from the Early Care and Education Bill Tracking Database, we employed Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA), a statistical topic identification model, to examine 2,396 ECE bills across the 50 U.S. states during the 2015-2018. First, a six-topic solution demonstrated the strongest fit theoretically and empirically suggesting two meta policy priorities: ‘ECE finance’ and ‘ECE services’. ‘ECE finance’ comprised three dimensions: (1) Revenues, (2) Expenditures, and (3) Fiscal Governance. ‘ECE services’ also included three dimensions: (1) PreK, (2) Child Care, and (3) Health and Human Services (HHS). Further, we found that bills covering a higher proportion of HHS, Fiscal Governance, or Expenditures were more likely to pass into law relative to bills focusing largely on PreK, Child Care, and Revenues. Additionally, legislative effectiveness of the bill’s primary sponsor was a strong predictor of legislative success, and further moderated the relation between bill content and passage. Highly effective legislators who had previously passed five or more bills had an extremely high probability of introducing a legislation that successfully passed regardless of topic. Legislation with expenditures as policy priorities benefitted the most from having an effective legislator. We conclude with a discussion of the empirical findings within the broader context of early childhood policy literature and suggest implications for future research and policy.

Leveraging Large Administrative Data for Special Education Policy Analysis: Recent Contributions and Future Directions

Does Special Education Work? A Systematic Literature Review of Evidence From Administrative Data

Expanding Law- and Policy-Relevant Discourse Within Special Education Research

Population-Level Administrative Data: A Resource to Advance Psychological Science

Prevalence of Research Design in Special Education: A Survey of Peer-Reviewed Journals

National Trends in Special Education and Academic Outcomes for English Learners With Disabilities

Gather-Narrow-Extract: A Framework for Studying Local Policy Variation Using Web-Scraping and Natural Language Processing

The national educational panel study (NEPS) and methodological innovations in longitudinal large-scale assessments

Unprecedented and unmasked: An analysis of how district policy documents frame special education during the COVID crisis

Estimating returns to special education: combining machine learning and text analysis to address confounding

A Call for Amicus Briefs as a Means to Influence Special Education Policy: Lessons Learned From Endrew F.

All a-board: sharing educational data science research with school districts

Choice, Mobility, and Classification: Disaggregating the Charter School Special Education Gap

Evaluating Special Education Instructional Practices Using Observation Rubrics: Investigating the Reliability of School Administrator Ratings

Translating sophisticated data analytic strategies regarding school attendance and absenteeism into targeted educational policy

Achieving Better Educational Practices Through Research Evidence: A Critical Analysis and Case Illustration of Benefits and Challenges

Specific Learning Disability Identification Practices in the USA: a Survey of Special Education Administrators

Using an Ever–English Learner Framework to Examine Disproportionality in Special Education

What predicts legislative success of early care and education policies?: Applications of machine learning and Natural Language Processing in a cross-state early childhood policy analysis

Finite Resources, Increasing Demands: Rural Children Left Behind? Educators Speak Out on Issues Facing Rural Special Education

"What about special ed?": Barriers and enablers for teaching with technology in special education