Abstract:Purpose In 2016, the oversight body for policing in England and Wales reported a national shortage of 5,000 qualified detectives and other investigators. Commissioned by the National Police Chiefs Council, this research critically assessed initiatives taken by the Police Service of England and Wales since that time to remedy that shortfall. The purpose of this study is to answer the question, "To what extent can fast-track investigator recruitment and training schemes enhance the PSEW's investigative capacity and capability?" Design/methodology/approach Between 2019 and 2020, the authors examined four cases in England and Wales. Three were novel fast-track programmes for new joiners. The fourth was an investigator resilience programme. This study was qualitative and interpretive in nature. The authors carried out systematic reviews of the literature on investigative policy and detective work. The authors reviewed internal evaluations completed by Forces A, B and C. The authors interviewed respondents (n = 82) and supplemented the interview data with survey data (n = 45; N = 127); the authors analysed the data thematically and reviewed the findings in the context of systems theory and social identity theory. Findings The major themes identified by the analysis presented in this study were marketing and recruitment, attrition and progression, acceptance of the trainees, training and trainees' welfare and well-being. The programmes were not as successful as they might have been because of systems failures. Principally, ineffective coordination of the programmes with other elements of the forces on which their success also relied (such as training, human resources and detective, departments). A critical limiting factor was the lack of experienced, skilled detectives able to train, support and mentor the trainees. Practical implications This paper provides empirical evidence of the efficacy of a whole systems approach to organisational change. This study evidences the crisis in police investigative practice that limits the service that the police can provide to victims and communities and ultimately threatens police legitimacy. This study provides insights from police practitioners into detective work in the modern era and highlights areas where improvement is necessary. The research on which this study is based was commissioned by the National Police Chiefs Council. Thus, there is institutional buy in to its findings. Originality/value With its roots firmly in empiricism, this paper presents the first scholarly evaluation of the police's attempts to make up a massive shortfall in investigators. To the best of the authors' knowledge, this paper presents the first attempt to explain the challenges the police faced in this context, thematically. This study's focus on systems and on human behaviour is intended to inform a wide audience beyond British policing.

Police personnel allocation and homicide clearance

Optimal scheduling for police patrol duties

Towards Understanding the Impact of Human Mobility on Police Allocation

Process mapping homicide investigations and estimating resource requirements for homicide units: Findings from a case study in the United States

How Much Time Should the Police Spend at Crime Hot Spots? Answers from a Police Agency Directed Randomized Field Trial in Sacramento, California

How Effective Are Police? The Problem of Clearance Rates and Criminal Accountability

Explainable Machine Learning for Predicting Homicide Clearance in the United States

Reducing police response times: Optimization and simulation of everyday police patrol

Helping the police with their inquiries: improving investigator resilience and capacity in England and Wales

Police organisation and deadly force: an examination of variation across large and small cities

Improving Policing: A Problem-Oriented Approach

A tale of two cities: Policing and firearm homicides in Boston and Philadelphia

The effect of highly publicized police killings on policing: Evidence from large U.S. cities

Optimal policing with (and without) criminal search

The Police Role in Domestic Homicide Prevention: Lessons From a Domestic Violence Death Review Committee

Police Staffing and Workload Assignment in Law Enforcement Using Multi-Server Queueing Models

Data-Driven Optimization for Police Beat Design in South Fulton, Georgia

Reducing homicide risk in Indianapolis between 1997 and 2000

Smart city planning focused on the US cities in need of policing innovations and public health safety technologies and strategies

Police violence in Canada and the USA: analysis and management

Efficient allocation of law enforcement resources using predictive police patrolling