Abstract:There is increasing interest in the prospects for managed market reforms in developing countries, stimulated by current reforms and policy debates in developed countries, and by perceptions of widespread public sector inefficiency in many countries. This review examines the prospects for such reforms in a developing country context, primarily by drawing on the arguments and evidence emerging from developed countries, with a specific focus on the provision of hospital services. The paper begins with a discussion of the current policy context of these reforms, and their main features. It argues that while current and proposed reforms vary in detail, most have in common the introduction of competition in the provision of health care, with the retention of a public monopoly of financing, and that this structure emerges from the dual goals of addressing current public sector inefficiencies while retaining the known equity and efficiency advantages of public health systems. The paper then explores the theoretical arguments and empirical evidence for and against these reforms, and examines their relevance for developing countries. Managed markets are argued to enhance both efficiency and equity. These arguments are analysed in terms of three distinct claims made by their proponents: that managed markets will promote increased provider competition, and hence, provider efficiency; that contractual relationships are more efficient than direct management; and that the benefits of managed markets will outweigh their costs. The analysis suggests that on all three issues, the theoretical arguments and empirical evidence remain ambiguous, and that this ambiguity is attributable in part to poor understanding of the behaviour of health sector agents within the market, and to the limited experience with these reforms. In the context of developing countries, the paper argues that most of the conditions required for successful implementation of these reforms are absent in all but a few, richer developing countries, and that the costs of these reforms, particularly in equity terms, are likely to pose substantial problems. Extensive managed market reforms are therefore unlikely to succeed, although limited introduction of particular elements of these reforms may be more successful. Developed country experience is useful in defining the conditions under which such limited reforms may succeed. There is an urgent need to evaluate the existing experience of different forms of contracting in developing countries, as well as to interpret emerging evidence from developed country reforms in the light of conditions in developing countries.

Market--what market? A review of Health Authority purchasing in the NHS internal market

An economic analysis of the limits of market based reforms in the English NHS

RESTRUCTURING THE NHS AGAIN: SUPPLY SIDE REFORM IN RECENT ENGLISH HEALTH CARE POLICY

Universal coverage and cost control: the United Kingdom National Health Service

Managing the health care market in developing countries: prospects and problems

Private Sector Involvement and Competition Have Not Improved Healthcare in England, Report Shows

Health services market testing--the experience of the community services review team in British Forces Germany

The impact of market oriented reforms on choice and information: a case study of cataract surgery in outer London and Stockholm

The economics of hospital reform from hierarchical to market-based incentives

The reorientation of market-oriented reforms in Swedish health-care

Commissioning for health improvement following the 2012 health and social care reforms in England: what has changed?

Health in China. the Healthcare Market.

Healthcare reform in the Netherlands: after 15 years of regulated competition

A decade of outsourcing in health and social care in England: What was it meant to achieve?

Morality, consumerism and the internal market in health care

Managed competition, governmentality and institutional response in the United Kingdom

Exploring limits to market-based reform: managed competition and rehabilitation home care services in Ontario

Knit Your Own Without a Pattern: Health Promotion Specialists in an Internal Market

Shared Governance within the market-oriented health care system of New Zealand

The long shadow of public policy; Barriers to a value-based approach in healthcare procurement

Regarding general practice: an appeal to the new UK Government