A world of uncertainties: litigation and order in a flood irrigation society: three villages in southern Shanxi since late imperial times

Junfeng ZHANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17535654.2023.2317616

2024-06-28

Abstract:Flood diversion irrigation is a unique way of water resource development and utilization in the semi-arid area of the South Shanxi Loess Plateau, a widespread technique since Wang Anshi's (1021–1086) political reforms in the Northern Song era (960–1127). The uncertainty of flooding has brought many uncertainties to an area that is completely dependent on fluvial submersion for its livelihood. Long-term water disputes between the villages of Kang, Yangshe and Chaili in southern Shanxi province thus became the basis of petty disputes and momentous lawsuits. Litigation thus became a behavioral habit to deal with the plight of subsistence. Government rulings were habitually violated by the villagers. To government offices at all levels, the repeated submission and adjudicating of water conservancy lawsuits by the Three Villages became a normal occurrence. Uncertainty over the supply of flood water led to uncertainty in society, and this in turn intensified the uncertainty concerning the availability of flood water, in particular in terms of socio-economic utilization. Only when the local economy became no longer completely dependent on flood waters for irrigation, this uncertainty began to minimize or even disappear. In this regard, uncertainty is a core concept for understanding the relationship between man and nature in the semi-arid Shanxi Loess Plateau, throughout and since the late imperial period.