The Risks and Benefits of Physician Practice Acquisition and Consolidation: A Narrative Review of Peer-Reviewed Publications Between 2009 and 2022 in the United States
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/jmdh.s463618
2024-05-14
Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare
Abstract:George Tewfik, Dennis Grech, Linda Laham, Faraz Chaudhry, Rotem Naftalovich Department of Anesthesiology, Rutgers New Jersey Medical School, Newark, NJ, 07103, USA Correspondence: George Tewfik, Rutgers New Jersey Medical School, Department of Anesthesiology, 185 South Orange Ave, Newark, NJ, 07103, USA, Tel +1-973 972-5007, Email The objective of this narrative review was to assess current literature regarding acquisition and consolidation of physician practices in the United States (US). The acquisition and consolidation of physician practices is a trend affecting patient care, quality of services, healthcare economics and the daily practice of physicians. As practices are acquired by fellow physician groups, private equity investors and entities such as hospitals or large healthcare systems, it is important to better understand the underlying forces driving these transactions and their effects. This is a narrative review of peer-reviewed publications to determine what current literature has covered regarding the acquisition and consolidation of physician practices in the US regarding risks and benefits of this trend. Sources included the SCOPUS, Medline- PUBMED and Web of Science databases. Peer reviewed publications from 2009 to 2022 were included for initial review and curation for relevance using the search terms "physician" and "practice" with either "acquisition" or "consolidation". Synthesis conducted after narrowing down of relevant articles did not use quantitative measurements, but instead examined overall trends, as well as risk and benefits of ongoing acquisition and consolidation in a narrative format. Journal articles focused on physician consolidation in the US often reported increases in physician numbers with decreases in numbers of individual practices. Private equity quantitative analyses reported rapidly accelerating acquisitions driven by these investors, and vertical integration scholarly work reported frequent geographic consolidation of nearby practitioners. Risks associated with these transactions included such items as decreased physician autonomy and higher cost of care. Benefits included practice stability, improved negotiation with insurers and improved access to resources. Keywords: healthcare economics, physician practice, physician practice acquisition, systematic review The acquisition and consolidation of physician practices is a well-documented phenomenon in the United States (US) that is likely closely associated with an ever-increasing web of legal and regulatory hurdles confronted by medical practitioners. 1–3 Physician practices may be acquired by hospitals and healthcare systems, private equity investors, 4–6 or practice management groups, who will directly employ the medical practitioners, and assume responsibility for financial and administrative matters. 7 Numerous potential consequences of this trend have been identified including increased market power with associated antitrust concerns, 8–10 increased healthcare spending on a per-patient basis, 11–16 modifications to physician compensation 17 and productivity, 18 and changes in referral patterns. 19,20 With the introduction and passage of the Affordable Care Act in 2009 and 2010, there were significant changes, and effects on, physician practice patterns both in clinical care and in the business of medicine. 21–23 The United States is unique in that it is the only high-income country in the world without a guaranteed right to healthcare access, and spends significantly more per citizen than comparable countries with worse outcomes in life expectancy at birth, maternal and infant mortality and suicide rates. 24 In the wake of the financial crisis in 2008 and 2009, financial pressures on all stakeholders in the healthcare system in the US caused an acceleration in the rise of corporate medicine, resulting in mergers and acquisitions of medical institutions and physician practices. 25 Physicians in acquired practices report unique stressors, such as the loss of clinical autonomy, 20,26 though many also reported improved work environments, improved psychological safety, and decreased rates of burnout in the new practice model. 27 Alternatively, some studies have found no effect on healthcare spending or use of specialty-specific procedures, suggesting no additional pressure on clinicians to meet performance standards following acquisition. 28 Physicians may be offered such incentives as higher pay with lower workloads to promote acquisition. 29 It is unclear if quality of care is affected by this trend. 30,31 The purpose of this review is to assess the current literature regarding consolidation of physician practices, and to effectively outline ass -Abstract Truncated-
health care sciences & services