Abstract:This paper presents a phenomenological study on the angle between the Standard and the Winner-Take-All (WTA) jet axes ($\Delta R_{\rm axis}^{\rm WTA-Std}$) in high-energy nuclear collisions. The $p$+$p$ baseline is provided by the Pythia8 event generator. The in-medium jet propagation is simulated by the linear Boltzmann transport (LBT) model, which considers both the elastic and inelastic jet-medium interactions. Our theoretical results calculated by the LBT model show that the $\Delta R_{\rm axis}^{\rm WTA-Std}$ distribution in Pb+Pb at $\sqrt{s}=5.02$ TeV is narrower than that in $p$+$p$, which agrees well with the recent ALICE measurements. The narrowing of $\Delta R_{\rm axis}^{\rm WTA-Std}$ seems to violate the $p_T$-broadening nature of the jet quenching effect, usually explained by the influence of "selection bias". However, the physical details still need to be fully understood. Utilizing a matching-jet method to track the jet evolution in the QGP to remove the selection bias in the Monte Carlo simulations, we observe that the $\Delta R_{\rm axis}^{\rm WTA-Std}$ distribution becomes broader due to the jet-medium interactions. At the same time, by rescaling the quark/gluon-jet fractions in Pb+Pb collisions to be the same as that in $p$+$p$, we find that the fraction change may not significantly influence the modification pattern of jet $\Delta R_{\rm axis}^{\rm WTA-Std}$. On the other hand, the selected jet sample in A+A collisions has a significantly narrower initial $\Delta R_{\rm axis}^{\rm WTA-Std}$ distribution than the $p$+$p$ baseline, and such a biased comparison between $p$+$p$ and A+A conceals the actual jet-broadening effect in the experimental measurements. The investigations presented in this paper will deepen our understanding of the relationship between the actual intra-jet modifications in the QGP and the experimental observations.

Phenomenological Relationship between the Ridge and Inclusive Distributions

Two-particle Correlations at High-Energy Nuclear Collisions, Peripheral-Tube Model Revisited

The ridge laboratory

Is the ridge formed by aligned jet propagation and medium flow?

The Ridge As a Shadowing Effect in Hydrodynamics

On the Origin of the Trigger-Angle Dependence of the Ridge Structure(Soft Interaction and Multiparticle Correlations,Multiparticle Dynamics)

Observation of a "Ridge" correlation structure in high multiplicity proton-proton collisions: A brief review

On the Origin of the Trigger-Angle Dependence of the Ridge Structure

Measurements of long-range two-particle correlation over a wide pseudorapidity range in p$-$Pb collisions at $\sqrt{s_{\rm NN}}=5.02$ TeV

Parton Distributions at Hadronization from Bulk Dense Matter Produced at RHIC

The study on the multiplicity dependence of ridge behavior in $pp$ collisions at $\sqrt{s}=13$ TeV at the LHC

Emergence of long-range angular correlations in low-multiplicity proton-proton collisions

Dynamics of particle-particle correlations and the ridge effect in proton-proton collisions

On connection of the cosmic-ray coplanarity of most energetic particles with the collider long-range near-side "ridge" effect

Hadronic nature of high-energy emission from the Galactic Ridge

Phenomenological study of the angle between jet axes in heavy-ion collisions

What did we know from the "ridge" in BEC at the CMS

Long Range Correlations and the Soft Ridge in Relativistic Nuclear Collisions

Studying Minijets Via The Pt Dependence Of 2-Particle Correlation In Azimuthal Angle-Phi

Predictions on three-particle azimuthal correlations in proton-proton collisions

Phenomenological Relation Between Distribution and Fragmentation Functions