Characterization and definability in modal first-order fragments

Facundo Carreiro

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1011.4718

2010-11-22

Abstract:Model theoretic results such as Characterization and Definability give important information about different logics. It is well known that the proofs of those results for several modal logics have, somehow, the same 'taste'. A general proof for most modal logics below first order is still too ambitious. In this thesis we plan to isolate sufficient conditions for the characterization and definability theorems to hold in a wide range of logics. Along with these conditions we will prove that, whichever logic that meets them, satisfies both theorems. Therefore, one could give an unifying proof for logics with already known results. Moreover, one will be able to prove characterization and definability results for logics that have not yet been investigated. In both cases, it is only needed to check that a logic meets the requirements to automatically derive the desired results.

Logic in Computer Science,Logic

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to provide a unified framework for proving characterization and definability theorems for modal fragments in first - order logic. Specifically, the author hopes to find sufficient conditions such that the characterization and definability theorems can hold in a wide range of modal logics that satisfy these conditions. In this way, it can provide unified proofs for logics with known results and new proof methods for logics that have not been studied yet.

### Core problems of the paper

1. **Characterization Theorem**:
- This theorem describes which formulas in first - order logic can be expressed by modal logic. For example, van Benthem's characterization theorem shows that a formula in first - order logic can be represented by a modal logic formula if it is invariant under all bisimulations.
- The formula is stated as follows:
\[
\text{For a first - order logic formula } \alpha, \alpha \text{ is equivalent to the translation } \phi^t \text{ of some modal logic formula } \phi \text{ if and only if } \alpha \text{ is invariant under all bisimulations}
\]

2. **Definability Theorem**:
- This theorem describes which model classes can be defined by modal logic formulas. For example, a model class \( K \) can be defined by a modal logic formula if and only if \( K \) is closed under bisimulations and ultraproducts.
- The formula is stated as follows:
\[
\text{A model class } K \text{ can be defined by a modal logic formula if and only if } K \text{ and its complement are closed under bisimulations and ultraproducts}
\]

### Methods and contributions of the paper

- **Construction of a general framework**: The author proposes a general framework for describing bisimulation relations in different modal logics. Through this framework, the characterization and definability of various modal logics can be systematically analyzed.
- **Determination of sufficient conditions**: The author determines certain sufficient conditions such that the characterization and definability theorems naturally hold in modal logics that satisfy these conditions.
- **Application examples**: The paper shows how to apply this framework to specific modal logics, such as hybrid logics and memory logics, verifying the effectiveness and wide applicability of this framework.

### Practical significance

These theoretical achievements are not only helpful for in - depth understanding of the properties of modal logic, but also have important significance in the practical applications of computer science. For example, in model checking, using modal logic can significantly improve performance because modal logic is usually more efficient than first - order logic. In addition, the bisimulation invariance of modal logic can also help simplify model - checking tasks and accelerate the verification process by minimizing models.

In summary, this paper aims to provide a unified theoretical framework for the characterization and definability of modal logic, thereby promoting the further development of modal logic in both theoretical and practical applications.