Solar Flares and Coronal Mass Ejections: A Statistically Determined Flare Flux-CME Mass Correlation

Alicia N. Aarnio,Keivan G. Stassun,W. Jeffrey Hughes,Sarah L. McGregor

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11207-010-9672-7

2010-11-02

Abstract:In an effort to examine the relationship between flare flux and corresponding CME mass, we temporally and spatially correlate all X-ray flares and CMEs in the LASCO and GOES archives from 1996 to 2006. We cross-reference 6,733 CMEs having well-measured masses against 12,050 X-ray flares having position information as determined from their optical counterparts. For a given flare, we search in time for CMEs which occur 10-80 minutes afterward, and we further require the flare and CME to occur within +/-45 degrees in position angle on the solar disk. There are 826 CME/flare pairs which fit these criteria. Comparing the flare fluxes with CME masses of these paired events, we find CME mass increases with flare flux, following an approximately log-linear, broken relationship: in the limit of lower flare fluxes, log(CME mass)~0.68*log(flare flux), and in the limit of higher flare fluxes, log(CME mass)~0.33*log(flare flux). We show that this broken power-law, and in particular the flatter slope at higher flare fluxes, may be due to an observational bias against CMEs associated with the most energetic flares: halo CMEs. Correcting for this bias yields a single power-law relationship of the form log(CME mass)~0.70*log(flare flux). This function describes the relationship between CME mass and flare flux over at least 3 dex in flare flux, from ~10^-7 to 10^-4 W m^-2.

Solar and Stellar Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **the relationship between solar flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs), especially the statistical correlation between flare flux and CME mass**.

Specifically, by analyzing X - ray flare and CME data in LASCO and GOES archives from 1996 to 2006, the authors attempt to answer the following questions:

1. **Is there a correlation between flare flux and CME mass?**
- The authors screen out eligible flare - CME pairs through temporal and spatial associations and study the flux - mass relationship between these pairs.

2. **What is the form of this correlation?**
- The authors find that at lower flare fluxes, there is an approximately log - linear relationship between CME mass and flare flux:
\[
\log(\text{CME mass}) \propto 0.68\times\log(\text{flare flux})
\]
At higher flare fluxes, this relationship becomes flatter:
\[
\log(\text{CME mass}) \propto 0.33\times\log(\text{flare flux})
\]

3. **Is this relationship affected by observational biases?**
- The authors note that in high - energy flares, the presence of halo CMEs may lead to observational biases. They attempt to correct this bias and arrive at a unified power - law relationship:
\[
\log(\text{CME mass}) \propto 0.70\times\log(\text{flare flux})
\]

4. **Over what range is this relationship valid?**
- The authors verify that this relationship is valid for at least 3 orders of magnitude of flare flux (from \(10^{-7}\) to \(10^{-4}\space\text{W m}^{-2}\)).

In summary, this paper aims to quantify the relationship between flare flux and CME mass through statistical methods and explore the performance of this relationship under different flare intensities and its possible physical mechanisms.