Abstract:Researchers have explored the performance of Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma strategies for decades, from the celebrated performance of Tit for Tat to the introduction of the zero-determinant strategies and the use of sophisticated learning structures such as neural networks. Many new strategies have been introduced and tested in a variety of tournaments and population dynamics. Typical results in the literature, however, rely on performance against a small number of somewhat arbitrarily selected strategies in a small number of tournaments, casting doubt on the generalizability of conclusions. In this work, we analyze a large collection of 195 strategies in thousands of computer tournaments, present the top performing strategies across multiple tournament types, and distill their salient features. The results show that there is not yet a single strategy that performs well in diverse Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma scenarios, nevertheless there are several properties that heavily influence the best performing strategies. This refines the properties described by Axelrod in light of recent and more diverse opponent populations to: be nice, be provocable and generous, be a little envious, be clever, and adapt to the environment. More precisely, we find that strategies perform best when their probability of cooperation matches the total tournament population's aggregate cooperation probabilities. The features of high performing strategies help cast some light on why strategies such as Tit For Tat performed historically well in tournaments and why zero-determinant strategies typically do not fare well in tournament settings. Furthermore, our findings have implications for the future training of autonomous agents, as understanding the crucial features for incorporation into these agents becomes essential.

A non-cooperative Pareto-efficient solution to a one-shot Prisoner's Dilemma

The Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma: Good Strategies and Their Dynamics

A solution concept for games with altruism and cooperation

Evolutionary Prisoner'S Dilemma Game Based on Division of Work

The Effect of Recommended Role Models in Prisoner’s Dilemma Game

Time and the Prisoner's Dilemma

Cooperation and self-regulation in a model of agents playing different games

Zero-determinant strategies in iterated multi-strategy games

Small Bots, Big Impact: Solving the Conundrum of Cooperation in Optional Prisoner's Dilemma Game through Simple Strategies

Iterated Prisoner’s Dilemma contains strategies that dominate any evolutionary opponent

Properties of Winning Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma Strategies

Payoff Control in the Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma

Generalized prisoner's dilemma

An Investigation of N-person Prisoners' Dilemmas

Evolutionary Prisoner’s Dilemma on Newman-Watts Social Networks with an Asymmetric Payoff Distribution Mechanism

Resolution of the stochastic strategy spatial prisoner's dilemma by means of particle swarm optimization

Selfish punishment with avoiding mechanism can alleviate both first-order and second-order social dilemma

An Adaptive Strategy Via Reinforcement Learning for the Prisoner's Dilemma Game

How much is convenient to defect? A method to estimate the cooperation probability in Prisoner's Dilemma and other games

Beyond Pairwise Strategy Updating in the Prisoner's Dilemma Game

Predicting Human Cooperation