Constraints on the Heating of High Temperature Active Region Loops: Observations from Hinode and SDO

Harry P. Warren,David H. Brooks,Amy R. Winebarger
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/734/2/90
2011-03-28
Abstract:We present observations of high temperature emission in the core of a solar active region using instruments on Hinode and SDO. These multi-instrument observations allow us to determine the distribution of plasma temperatures and follow the evolution of emission at different temperatures. We find that at the apex of the high temperature loops the emission measure distribution is strongly peaked near 4 MK and falls off sharply at both higher and lower temperatures. Perhaps most significantly, the emission measure at 0.5 MK is reduced by more than two orders of magnitude from the peak at 4 MK. We also find that the temporal evolution in broad-band soft X-ray images is relatively constant over about 6 hours of observing. Observations in the cooler SDO/AIA bandpasses generally do not show cooling loops in the core of the active region, consistent with the steady emission observed at high temperatures. These observations suggest that the high temperature loops observed in the core of an active region are close to equilibrium. We find that it is possible to reproduce the relative intensities of high temperature emission lines with a simple, high-frequency heating scenario where heating events occur on time scales much less than a cooling time. In contrast, low-frequency heating scenarios, which are commonly invoked to describe nanoflare models of coronal heating, do not reproduce the relative intensities of high temperature emission lines and predict low-temperature emission that is approximately an order of magnitude too large. We also present an initial look at images from the SDO/AIA 94 A channel, which is sensitive to Fe XVIII.
Solar and Stellar Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the heating mechanism of high - temperature plasma loops in the core of solar active regions. Specifically, by analyzing multi - instrument observational data from the Hinode satellite and the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO), the author explored the temperature distribution in high - temperature plasma loops in the active region core and its evolution over time. The main objectives of the paper are: 1. **Determine the temperature distribution in high - temperature plasma loops in the active region core**: By analyzing the emission measure (EM) at different temperatures, understand the physical conditions of these high - temperature loops. 2. **Study the evolution of high - temperature plasma loops**: Through long - term observations, analyze the changes in radiation intensity of these high - temperature loops at different temperatures to determine whether they are in an equilibrium state. 3. **Verify different heating models**: By comparing the observational results with the predictions of low - frequency heating and high - frequency heating models, evaluate the effectiveness of these models. ### Main findings - **Temperature distribution**: The emission measure distribution (EM distribution) of high - temperature plasma loops peaks at approximately 4 MK and drops rapidly at higher and lower temperatures. In particular, the emission measure at 0.5 MK is two orders of magnitude lower than that at 4 MK. - **Time evolution**: During the approximately 6 - hour observation time, the radiation intensity in broadband soft X - ray images is relatively constant. - **Absence of cooling loops**: In the core of the active region, no cooling loops were observed in the cooler SDO/AIA band observations, which is consistent with the stable radiation of high - temperature loops. - **Comparison of heating models**: A simple high - frequency heating model can reproduce the relative intensities of high - temperature emission lines, while the low - frequency heating model cannot explain the observational results, especially the predicted low - temperature emission is much higher than the actual observed value. ### Conclusion The conclusion of the paper is that the high - temperature plasma loops in the core of the active region are close to an equilibrium state, and the high - frequency heating model can better explain the relative intensities of the observed high - temperature emission lines. In contrast, the low - frequency heating model (such as the nanoflare model) cannot reproduce the observational results, especially there are significant differences in low - temperature emission. These findings are of great significance for understanding the solar corona heating mechanism.