D. Schönberner,R. Jacob,C. Sandin,M. Steffen
Abstract:By means of hydrodynamical models we do the first investigations of how the properties of planetary nebulae are affected by their metal content and what can be learned from spatially unresolved spectrograms of planetary nebulae in distant stellar systems. We computed a new series of 1D radiation-hydrodynamics planetary nebulae model sequences with central stars of 0.595 M_sun surrounded by initial envelope structures that differ only by their metal content. At selected phases along the evolutionary path, the hydrodynamic terms were switched off, allowing the models to relax for fixed radial structure and radiation field into their equilibrium state with respect to energy and ionisation. The analyses of the line spectra emitted from both the dynamical and static models enabled us to systematically study the influence of hydrodynamics as a function of metallicity and evolution. We also recomputed selected sequences already used in previous publications, but now with different metal abundances. These sequences were used to study the expansion properties of planetary nebulae close to the bright cut-off of the planetary nebula luminosity function. Our simulations show that the metal content strongly influences the expansion of planetary nebulae: the lower the metal content, the weaker the pressure of the stellar wind bubble, but the faster the expansion of the outer shell because of the higher electron temperature. This is in variance with the predictions of the interacting-stellar-winds model (or its variants) according to which only the central-star wind is thought to be responsible for driving the expansion of a planetary nebula. Metal-poor objects around slowly evolving central stars become very dilute and are prone to depart from thermal equilibrium because then adiabatic expansion contributes to gas cooling. ...abridged abstract.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the evolutionary characteristics of planetary nebulae (PNs) under different metallicity conditions and their influence on the observation of planetary nebulae in distant galaxies. Specifically, the researchers explored how the metal content of planetary nebulae affects their properties through hydrodynamic models and what information can be obtained from spatially unresolved spectrograms. In addition, they also paid special attention to the relationship between the expansion speed of planetary nebulae under different metallicity conditions and the metallicity of their parent star populations, and under what conditions the standard photoionization model may fail.
### Research Background and Objectives
- **Background**: Planetary nebulae are in the late stage of stellar evolution, and their spectral and dynamic characteristics are very valuable for studying star populations in galaxies. However, it is not yet clear how these characteristics will change under different metallicities, especially in low - metallicity environments.
- **Objectives**:
- Explore how the metal content of planetary nebulae affects their expansion speed and other physical characteristics.
- Analyze the spectral characteristics of planetary nebulae under different metallicity conditions, especially unresolved spectrograms.
- Verify existing theoretical models, especially the Interacting - Stellar - Winds Model, to see if they can explain the observed phenomena.
- Study whether the photoionization model is still valid under low - metallicity conditions.
### Methods
- **Model**: The researchers used a one - dimensional radiative hydrodynamic model to simulate the evolution process of planetary nebulae under different metallicity conditions. These models include changes in the mass of the central star, the initial envelope structure, and metallicity.
- **Simulation**: At the selected evolution stage, the hydrodynamic term was turned off, allowing the model to reach an energy and ionization equilibrium state under a fixed radial structure and radiation field. By analyzing the line spectra emitted by the dynamic and static models, the influence of hydrodynamics was systematically studied.
### Main Results
- **Influence of Metallicity on Expansion Speed**: The simulation results show that the lower the metallicity, the faster the expansion speed of the planetary nebula, because the electron temperature is higher, resulting in greater thermal pressure. This is inconsistent with the prediction of the Interacting - Stellar - Winds Model, which believes that the wind pressure of the central star is the main factor driving the expansion.
- **Non - equilibrium Effects at Low Metallicity**: Planetary nebulae with low metallicity become very thin around slowly evolving central stars and are prone to deviate from thermal equilibrium because the contribution of adiabatic expansion to gas cooling increases.
- **Observation Verification**: The expansion speed based on the volume - integrated line profile width is very consistent with the observation results of distant galaxies. In particular, for celestial bodies close to the bright cut - off point of the planetary nebula luminosity function, their central star masses are large (> 0.6 M⊙), and the optical thickness of the nebula shell is high.
### Conclusions
- **Model Explanation**: The research results show that the expansion characteristics of planetary nebulae under different metallicity conditions can be well explained by the one - dimensional radiative hydrodynamic model. This proves that the formation and acceleration of planetary nebulae are mainly caused by the ionization and heating of the stellar radiation field, and the role of the shock - compressed stellar wind pressure is smaller.
- **Limitations of the Photoionization Model**: In some cases, especially when expansion cooling needs to be considered, the standard photoionization model may have problems.
Through these studies, the author provides important theoretical support for understanding the evolution of planetary nebulae under different metallicity conditions and provides a new direction for future research.