Abstract:Purpose As consumers read multiple reviews, so consumer review consistency is important. The purpose of this paper is to investigate the role of consumer review consistency in influencing attitudes toward brands by examining its underlying effect on consumers’ emotions after they read consistent consumer reviews. In addition, the moderation effect of hedonic and utilitarian purchase values on positive consumer emotions and attitudes toward brands is explored. Design/methodology/approach This study used a quantitative design in which 329 participants – undergraduate and MBA students at a university in Taiwan – were asked to complete online questionnaires. To generalize the results, the questions in the questionnaire were based on any consumer reviews that the participants had recently browsed. Findings Consumer review consistency positively influences attitudes toward brands. Positive emotions are also developed when reading consistent consumer reviews, and this positively influences consumers’ attitudes toward brands. However, positive emotions are not derived from consistent consumer reviews in all contexts. The results show that positive emotions work well when consumers shop using hedonic value. Positive emotions create positive consumers’ attitudes toward a brand when they shop using hedonic value, but this significant effect does not occur when consumers shop using utilitarian value. Research limitations/implications This study’s results suggest that only investigating the quality of a consumer review or other aspects of a single review might overlook the impact of consumer review consistency, as consumers read multiple reviews. Consumer review consistency plays an important role in brand effectiveness, as consumers form positive attitudes toward brands when they read consistent reviews. Positive emotions can strengthen consumers’ attitudes toward a brand. Moreover, positive emotions increase positive attitudes toward brands only when consumers shop using hedonic value. However, positive emotions do not enhance consumers’ attitudes if they shop using utilitarian value. Practical implications Rather than focusing on the quality of a single review, online shops should carefully consider consumer review consistency. Although positive reviews are better than negative reviews, it is quite difficult for every shop to maintain 100 percent positive reviews. Therefore, maintaining and offering quality products and services are rather important to acquiring more positive reviews. Online shops should consider experimental marketing strategies when managing online shops. The layout of online sites that show consistent consumer reviews can provide consumers with cues that shorten decision making, especially for products that consumers tend to shop for using hedonic value. Originality/value This research extends the previous consumer review literature. Previous research was focused mainly on the quality of consumer reviews or other aspects of a single review. This research shows that focusing a single consumer review is not sufficient, as consumers generally read more than one consumer review. In addition, the role of positive emotions as a mediator between consumer review consistency and attitudes toward a brand was investigated. Furthermore, the moderated mediation effect was applied to investigate the role of shopping value (hedonic vs utilitarian value) as a moderator of positive emotions’ mediation effect.

Digital Therapy for Negative Consumption Experiences: The Impact of Emotional and Rational Reviews on Review Writers

The Enhancing Versus Backfiring Effects of Positive Emotion in Consumer Reviews

Positive Effects of Negative Reviews: an Eye-Tracking Perspective

A Study of the Mechanism of the Types of Emotions in Retailers' Review Request Text on Consumers' Reviewing Intention

Alleviating Hedonic Adaptation in Repeat Consumption with Creative Thinking

Unveiling Emotional Intensity in Online Reviews: Adopting Advanced Machine Learning Techniques

Emotion as signal of product quality

The Upside of Negative: Social Distance in Online Reviews of Identity-Relevant Brands

Negative online reviews, brand equity and emotional contagion

The Effect of Reviewers’ Self-Disclosure of Personal Review Record on Consumer Purchase Decisions: An ERPs Investigation

The Emotional Dimensions of Retail Therapy: A Literature Review

Effect of Displayed Ratings on Provision of Emotional Online Reviews.

How Do Expressed Emotions Affect the Helpfulness of a Product Review? Evidence from Reviews Using Latent Semantic Analysis

Behavioral Patterns beyond Posting Negative Reviews Online: An Empirical View

The mechanism of positive emotions linking consumer review consistency to brand attitudes

Positive emotions help rank negative reviews in e-commerce

In Search of Negativity Bias: An Empirical Study of Perceived Helpfulness of Online Reviews

Negative Reviews, Positive Impact: Consumer Empathetic Responding to Unfair Word of Mouth

How do online consumers review negatively?

Positive emotions help rank negative reviews for sellers and producers in e-commerce

“Worse Than What I Read?” the External Effect of Review Ratings on the Online Review Generation Process: an Empirical Analysis of Multiple Product Categories Using Amazon.com Review Data