Abstract:Causality theory is a complex field involving philosophy, mathematics, and computer science. It relies on the temporal precedence of cause over a consequence or unidirectional propagation of changes. Despite these simple principles, normative modeling of causal relationships is conceptually and computationally challenging. Model-free approaches provide insights into large, complex, and chaotic networks, but suffer from false positive and false negative inferences caused by meaningless statistical and temporal correlations. Machine learning advancements have extended these data-driven methods to nonlinear systems, yet inherited similar drawbacks as linear approaches. Interestingly, newer proposals within this model-free paradigm reverse the temporal precedence using the internal structure of the driven variable to recover information from the driving one. Efficient machine learning models combined with these state space reconstruction methods automate part of the process, potentially reducing inductive biases during training and inference. However, their translation into neuroscience, especially neuroimaging, is limited due to complex interpretations and a lack of systematic analyses of the results. Here, we exploited these methods combining them with normative analyses to reconstruct chaotic relationships and networks emerging from neuroimaging data. We validated the proposed scores with a chaotic yet solved system and rebuilt brain networks both in synthetic and real scenarios. We compared our method and heuristics with well-established alternatives providing a comprehensive and transparent benchmark. We obtained higher accuracies and reduced false inferences compared to Granger causality in tasks with known ground truth. When tested to unravel directed influences in brain networks meaningful predictions were found to exist between nodes from the default mode network. The presented framework explores reservoir computing for causality detection, offering a conceptual detour from traditional premises and has the potential to provide theoretical guidance opening perspectives for studying cognition and neuropathologies.

Topological reversibility and causality in feed-forward networks

Size-varying reversible causal graph dynamics

Nonlinear dynamical systems: Time reversibility {\it versus} sensitivity to the initial conditions

Inferring network topology from complex dynamics

Topology Inference for Networked Dynamical Systems - A Causality and Correlation Perspective.

Topological Evolution of Dynamical Networks: Global Criticality from Local Dynamics

Nonlinear dynamical systems: Time reversibility versus sensitivity to the initial conditions

Topological phases in discrete stochastic systems

Tracking Switched Dynamic Network Topologies from Information Cascades

Bridging Causal Reversibility and Time Reversibility: A Stochastic Process Algebraic Approach

Directed networks and resting-state effective brain connectivity with state-space reconstruction using reservoir computing causality

Controllability of flow-conservation networks

Topological phase transitions of random networks

Let's do the time-warp-attend: Learning topological invariants of dynamical systems

On Topology Inference for Networked Dynamical Systems: Principles and Performances.

Network bypasses sustain complexity

Noise-induced network topologies

The Topology of Causality

Topology Inference for Network Systems: Causality Perspective and Non-asymptotic Performance

How to Pare a Pair: Topology Control and Pruning in Intertwined Complex Networks

Time reversibility from visibility graphs of non-stationary processes